Islip Insurance Rates:

Islip, NY homeowners insurance is about $544 to $737, about $45-$61/month. Our exhaustive guide shows customers can save as much as $256 by comparing different quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Latest Home Insurance Reviews

Liberty Mutual
So far I have been quite satisfied with Liberty Mutual, and I trust them. Since I haven't had to file a claim, I do not know how that part of the company works. Hopefully, as well as the rest that I've dealt with so far.
Farmer's Insurance
Customer service, premiums are too high
State Farm
Statefarm overall is professional and quick, They have competitive prices in assuming and want to keep your business whenever possible. I would recommend them for insurance to anyone
Erie Insurance
The premiums are high, but I don't know what other companies charge so I can't say that they are more expensive than other ones are. I guess homeowners insurance is just expensive overall.
As I've said they have always treated me great and I've never had any issues after having services with them for 8 years.
I would definitely recommend USAA for customers seeking home insurance. They are trustworthy and honest. Their customer service is most excellent.
Of course, it would be great if the premium were even less. Perhaps they could reduce the deductible each year we're claim free like they do for our auto insurance.
American National Property And Casualty Company
I don't like the fact that when agents change or leave that the customers are just automatically assigned someone even if they are not in your area. I know that they will replace an agent in your area when one leaves, but it would be nice to communicate this is a more professional way than you logging into your account and seeing a new agent.
I love that the company I deal with gets to know me on a personal level! I have a great experience with them every time I chat with them!
State Farm
State farm has done a great job of handling my roof claim after hurricane harvey. i called and put a claim in right away, and they took care of it quickly!
I think they should improve the attention to the internet portal because i could not achieve all the objectives i needed without having to move from my office
Usaa is a very well known company in the united states. because they are so well known, they are held to a high standard.
The company website is very easy to navigate and use. I don't have to call the company, I can usually find what I need on the website.
The company is very easy to deal with and straightforward on all costs. They do not try to price gauge and are genuinely interested in making sure we have the best for our valuations.
Farmer's Insurance
We have always had pleasant communication with our insurance company. We hear from them yearly to discuss our rate and to get notification that our mortgage escrow is set up to pay them yearly.
State Farm
I like my company’s customer service. I've never had any issues getting in contact with them. I've always been able to get things done in a timely manner.
It's very generic. It doesn't offer live could be more informative.
Overall, my satisfaction with the company lies with the level of professionalism, the service when I choose to call in, the lack of overselling items, the willingness to run through all of the pricing scenarios, and the overall cost and dividend.
Safeco Insurance
The premium keeps increasing every single year. It never goes down and it never stays the same. It would be nice if one of these years it would at least stay the same.
Erie Insurance
The premium is very high. Other companies offer insurance for a lower premium. I am not sure about switching to another company.
Our Nationwide office has reasonable prices and friendly staff. We have used them for years without any issues.They are hard to beat.

Islip, NY Homeowners Insurance By Home Value

Islip, NY Home Value Total Homes % of Total Average Islip, NY Homeowners Insurance
Less than $50,000 1,306 2.0% $38
$100,000 to $124,999 507 1.0% $185
$150,000 to $174,999 1,351 2.0% $275
$175,000 to $199,999 1,497 3.0% $320
$200,000 to $249,999 5,277 10.0% $384
$250,000 to $299,999 9,098 18.0% $473
$300,000 to $399,999 28,630 58.0% $601

Top Home Insurance Agents Near Islip, NY

Home Insurance Company Near Islip, NY Homeowners Insurance Agency Near Islip, NY Address
State Farm James Piscitelli 23436 Merrick Blvd, Rosedale, NY, 11422-1320
Nationwide Kenrick C Chow 11325 Queens Blvd Ste 111, Forest Hills, NY, 11375
Travelers Mintz Girgan & Brightly 18 W Passaic St Rochelle Park, Rochelle Park, NJ, 7662
NA Employee Experts, Llc 2620 Peconic Ave, Seaford, NY, 11783
Travelers Best Coverage Insurance Brokerage Corp 250 GRAND ST 3RD FLR, NEW YORK, NY, 10002

Cost Of Homeowners Insurance By Street Near Islip, NY

Streets in Islip Area Homeowners Insurance Cost
Saint Marks Ln, Kings Ct, Cirrus Rd, Peter Farber St, Joseph St, Abbey Ln, W Beech St, Colorado Ave, Krause St, S 2nd St$628
Joan Rd, Lawrence Ln, Argosy St, Owens St, Maynard Ln, Belinda Ct, Suydam Ln, Franklyn Ave, Orville Dr, Laverne Ave$637
McGrath St, Cortelyou St, Shore Ln, Craig B Gariepy Ave, Oak, Woods Edge Ct, Beech Rd, Hollow Path Ct, Scopelitis Ct, Kirk Rd$620
Bataan Dr, Maine Ave, Pine Edge Ave, Peach St, Woodcliff Rd, Greenway Ter, Kathleen Dr, Penataquit Dr, Missouri Ave, Hiawatha Dr$644
Beaulieu Ct, Mariners Cir, Palmer Cir, Bay 5, Fordham Pl, Cookie Ln, Sycora Ln, Elward Ave, Duffy Pl, Blue Jay Dr$697
Clarissa Dr, Jenna Ct, Sand Ln, Arnold St, Dillmont St, Orient Ave, Drexel Dr, Rolling Wood Ct, Buttercup Dr, Liberty$625
Leopold Ave, Avis Dr, Jules Ct, Slope Ln, Chapin Ct, Joseph St Exd, Schneider la, Southport St, Sherwood Ln, Willowview Ct$638
Navy Walk, Frog Ln, Leona St, Chelsea Ct, Princeton St, Glenmere Way, Shadybrook Ln, Yew Ct, Rocket Dr, Kent Ct$624
Heller Pl, Albert St, Charles Ave, Woodlea Ln, Monte Cristo Walk, Clovernook Ave, Langdon St, Seusing Blvd, Wildwood Ct, Oceanbreeze Walk$627
Drew Ct, William Ave, Live Oak Dr, Henry Pl, S Park Ave, Bergold St, Tanglewood Rd, Ellen St, Garretson Ave, Chase Ln$655

Islip, NY Home Insurance Savings For Senior Occupied Homes

PlaceSavings For Senior Occupied Homes
Islip$96 to $98
East Islip$97
Great River$105
Islip Terrace$96

Islip, NY Auto & Homeowners Insurance Bundling Discounts

Place 1 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance 2 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance 3 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance
East Islip CDP, New York $81 $108 $162
Great River CDP, New York $88 $117 $175
Islip Terrace CDP, New York $80 $107 $160

Islip, NY Area Home Insurance as a % of Housing Cost

PlaceHome insurance as a % of housing cost for homes with mortgageHome insurance as a % of housing cost for homes without mortgage
Islip, NY1.9%5.3%
East Islip1.72%5.39%
Great River1.46%5.83%
Islip Terrace1.67%5.34%

Islip Renters Insurance as a Percentage of Rent

Islip Home By Monthly Rent Total Homes % of Total Estimated Monthly Income To Afford Rented House Including Renters Insurance
$200 to $299 606 2.0% $775
$300 to $499 694 3.0% $1225
$500 to $749 1,260 5.0% $1900
$750 to $999 1,676 7.0% $2650
$1,000 to $1,499 7,086 32.0% $3775
$1,500 or more 10,500 47.0% $5425