Top Ohio Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Ohio homeowners insurance is roughly $797. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $278 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Ohio Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 21.48
Allstate 10.93
Cincinnati Insurance 3.9
Erie Insurance 5.11
Marion mutual -
Auto Owners -
Progressive -
Geico -
Liberty Mutual 8.25
Farmer's Insurance -
Safeco -
Travelers -
Pike Mutual -
Farmers Insurance -
westgate insurance company -
CIC Agency -
Nationwide 8.06
USAA 3.32
MetLife -
American Family 3.1
National General -
Grange Insurance -
Allied Insurance -
Amica Mutual Insurance -
Safeco Insurance -
American Modern Insurance -
Auto Owners Insurance -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Safeco Home Insurance Reviews

We really like Safeco because we had a very good experience with our roof. They came out the day after we called and after the roof was inspected we got a check that day, minus the deductible. The company was very easy to work with and helpful.

Right now we have no complaints about our insurance company. Our recent claim was handled quickly and went very smoothly.

National General Home Insurance Reviews

I do not like that insurance is required by law. It allows them to charge more for their service and make a lot of money off of hard-working people.

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews

I am very satisfied with the company. They are very easy to contact with any questions or concerns, The prices are great for the amount of coverage.

So far I haven't found anything I dislike about the company.

Grange Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that I have easy access to the documents that I need to print off like my statement or to make an online payment if needed

Geico Home Insurance Reviews

I have never had insurance with any other company. I would not know what the other company’s price are.

easy to claiming process of the amount respect our staffs see my house suddenly process

I really cannot think of anything that I do not like about the company. They are wonderful and the prices are great.

The company is great. I won't go anywhere else until they prove me otherwise. I have my car through them and everything is easily accessed in one location. Everything is user-friendly, customer service is polite and knowledgeable, as well as understanding, and my premiums are outstanding for what is provided.

Pike Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that they are a fairly local company and that they would give me coverage at a fair price when others wouldn't

I don't like the fact that one of their rate increases seemed unfair to me. I also don't like that they haven't contacted me at least once over the past 5 years.

Erie Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like everything about the company. I will tell whoever will listen to me how happy I am with Erie. I have sent many people to Erie and they have now switched. They just go above and beyond for their customers and treat them with respect. They are really the best out there.

My insurance company is there for me when and if I need them. They provide me with the answers and polices that I need. The customer service and agents are very knowledgeable and know their stuff.

I love the fact that the company always seems to care about me and my opinion. They always seem to do anything they have to do to ensure that I get the best deal and best rates.

I have done business with My insurance agent for many years. She goes out of her way to let me know of anything new or a problem I need to know about.

There really is nothing that I dislike about the company. If I had to pick one thing, I guess I would like longer hours. If you work late then that would make it nice if you needed to get in contact with someone from the local office.

This premium is very affordable and fair especially as bundled with my auto insurance. Erie has always been fair, helpful and affordable to me

There is nothing that I dislike about this company. As I have said, they are truly one of the best around. Their premiums cannot be beaten for the amount of coverage that you get. I really cannot write anything that I dislike about them because that would be me just making something up.

Allied Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Nothing in particular. The only thing they could do better would be to lower my rates or give me better coverage at no extra cost. Until I have to interact with them for some reason, these are the only criteria I can really judge them by.

Amica Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I have a problem with some of the employees since they are not aware of the customer's complaints but the rest is good

Marion mutual Home Insurance Reviews

The insurance company is very friendly and they are also very helpful. They also go out of their way to get you good deals.

Overall i had a great positive impression towards the company and I would recommend this company to others

The company is great, I have never had a problem getting the answers I needed and getting the information that is required.

I don't have many dislikes except for the deductible when it comes to naming storm damage. I think it is quite high but I have shopped around and all insurance are running about the same

The only thing I don't like is that they are constantly checking in and expect you to upgrade stuff on your house.

Only with the premium amount I was a bit disappointed but rest of the things I am ok

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Again I like our agent in particular. He has treated us like family from day one and shows genuine concern for our needs when it comes to insurance.

I don't really have anything to complain about when it comes to this company. I have always had a pleasant experience when dealing with them.

Cincinnati Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that the company is friendly and the customer service representatives are wonderful. I also like that they take the time to explain my coverage to me fully, even before I bought it.

I don't like that the website is clunky and I get my bill way too close to the deadline so I feel pressured to pay immediately. I also don't like how pricey the insurance is despite the low value of my home and car.

Easy to work with, local to the Cincinnati area, long and prestigious past in the area. I really like working with them and their coverage and people.

Their rates are probably higher than others. I'd consider shopping around if I could find good coverage for less money.

Communicated via email and phone and mail. All questions have been answered promptly and well. Good doing business with them.

They are local and responsive. They have good service and fare rates. They are easy to work with and haven't given us too much hassle.

I think it's a bit higher. I'd be willing to shop around and find another around renewal time. Doesn't hurt to see what my options are.

It's fine when I've used it. I can get my insurance info and look at other products. Most of my interaction has been a local agent though.

They have been very responsive and handled things in a professional manner. Highly recommended. Good company to work with. Like them.

I'd like less premium I guess but considering the service I've gotten, it's not bad really. They are a good company to have in our corner.

They are local, easy to work with and have been helpful through the years on the rare occasions we have had to use them for claims.

I like that the company was able to provide the same amount of coverage for less than any other company quoted us.

They have been easy to work with and responsive. The premium hasn't been too much and it has been easy to work with or make changes as needed.

I like that it's hands off and a professional does all the work. I get high value for the money and feel like I'm a person and a customer, not just an account number.

I'm happy with them. I can't think of anything i dislike per se. I'd recommend them to anyone in a heartbeat. They are a good company to be covered by.

Safeco Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I do like that they help match cost to keep me as a customer and they do always answer questions or call back quickly. I also like that the agent has an office close by if I ever need to speak to a person.

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The company's overall prices seem high to me. They are higher than what I would like to be paying. They send too many solicitations for additional options, trying to sell me more coverage or add-ons.

My insurance agent is always available to talk to if I have questions. If he is away from the phone when I call, he always gets back to me in a timely manner.

I love farmer's because they are providing me with way more coverage than other companies for a lesser price, and the endorsements on the policy make me feel very safe as a homeowner

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

I like the good customer service and the added benefit of roadside assistance. they always answer quickly and are very helpful. Always ready to answer questions

I'm satisfied with the company itself but with my budget becoming tighter I want to see if they are still my best option. They have always been more than helpful and accommodating when needed

I think their rates are increasing and will likely surpass other companies soon. it will be likely that we will switch in the near future because of the price creeping upwards.

I assume they will cover my claim if I ever need to file one.

westgate insurance company Home Insurance Reviews

Erie insurance has had an excellent reputation for over 20 years. They keep on growing and want to care about their clients.

There is nothing I dislike about Erie Insurance. They satisfy my needs all the time. They want to make my experience a great one.

Auto Owners Home Insurance Reviews

I am very satisfied with the insurance company, and a good part of that reason is because we have an excellent agent and the insurance agency is very small and local.

I hate insurance companies in general, we all know you do not get what you pay for and that the contract is most likely against you

I feel like I don't quite have enough control over my interactions with my insurance policy because I have to go through my local insurance agency - which operates on kind of limited hours. Also, my local agency does not have any way for me to interact with them on the web,

The only knock on customer service is that we have to go through our local insurance agency instead of being able to deal directly with the Auto Owners Insurance Company. This can create gaps in pertinent information.

They quickly reply to your messages or calls and are eager to work with you. I have an agent that helps me with all the things that are related to my business with them

I don't really have many complaints about the company thus far. If anything, I would say they need more available on their webpage and mobile app and would like to see more options for lower deductibles.

CIC Agency Home Insurance Reviews

The most important thing for me with my insurance company is communication and ability to handle my claims effectively and timely. So far I have had no issues with either of these.

I do not know much about the actual company. My communication has been over the phone or via e-mail. I have not shopped around for other prices so I do not know how competitive they are. I do know we switched car insurance from USAA to CIC and it was a much better cost for the same coverage.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

I like the coverage amounts through Nationwide. I think they provide good comprehensive coverage and that's why I've stayed with them.

I dislike the premiums through Nationwide. It seems very high even though the coverage is good. I may look elsewhere in the future.

USAA Home Insurance Reviews

I like that I have easy access to everything I need online, and I have multiple ways to contact my insurance when I need to. I can change my coverage to meet my needs, and they always respond quickly and thoroughly.

I don't have anything that I dislike about USAA. I have been using them for insurance for years, and I've always been very happy with what I get from them. I've never been able to find the same level of service for the same price from any other insurance company.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

Good and very nice people. Not too expensive, the cheapest that I could get in the area. Also quick with claims and reasonable.

I feel like I couldn't get a notice when my bill goes up. Every year my bill increases but j never find out about it beforehand.

The appearance of the website is very much professional. The color scheme of the website is very much elegant and good.

It’s not that descriptive, and everything is not clearly mentioned. It should be attractive and useful, even it is not useful

Customer service has always been excellent. They are always there to answer questions and seem to want to take care of my needs.

I think the downside is the size of the company. Sometimes they might be a little impersonal and difficult to deal with if you need to file a claim,

So far, I have been satisfied with our coverage. We haven't yet submitted a claim, but I have a positive impression of the company overall.

The company is very good because they are very active when I need to make a claim. They are also well known and cheaper than other premiums and insurances out there. I'm able to adjust my deductible and plans whenever I need to to fit my needs. They are very helpful.

overall I feel that Allstate is one of those best bangs for your bucks company's where my dollar really stretches and I get a phenomenal bit of coverage for my home and auto

Our premium has doubled over the last 15 years. while I recognize prices will go up we have never had a claim so for it to double seems a bit excessive

They are a well-known company that I don't have to worry too much about. It is there and I can ignore it.

Of course, I would always like to save more money, but I understand why the prices are the way they are after having to file a claim

I like the company because of the size of the company. A company this size is solvent and too big to fail If there ever was a problem with claims the government would have to pay.

I like my insurance agent. I have been with him so long that he knows me and will try to assist with anything I need.

You have to wait for them to call you back. They don't answer the phone when you call. It takes them around a couple of hours to call back.

I have had them for over 20 years I cannot find a reason for disliking them.

Resonse time can take awhile.Over all I enjoy the company and really do not have anything that I dislike about it.

I think there are far too many questions. People have places to be, enough with the questions. Just get on with the show, less info and more depth in the processing. Think of it like mental technology.

ASI Home Insurance Reviews

The company offers me cheap premiums and great customer service. I am sure my claim free history, and long history has much to do with this, but it's comforting knowing I am not paying an arm and a leg now, and I have coverage if something does happen in the future.

I wish I could use my phone to participate in usage-based insurance. I would feel better if I could open my app and see how I have been doing but then also give comments about what was going on when I was driving which could be taken into consideration for my rates.

MetLife Home Insurance Reviews

Generally speaking, I get great prices, service, and support from Metlife. I do not see myself changing company's anytime soon as I have no complaints.

There is nothing. Generally speaking, I get great prices, service, and support from Metlife. I do not see myself changing company's anytime soon as I have no complaints.

American Family Home Insurance Reviews

There is really nothing that I dislike about having American Family as my insurance provider. They are always upfront with me and will work with me on any issues that I have.

I am quite satisfied about the company.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

I've been with progressive auto for about 7 years, and the rates were great. Going down every single year. So when I bought my home insurance the premiums fell even more. What's not to like about it?

Their customer service is great, I am the type of person to ask a million and one questions when it comes to insurance costs, and coverage. They are patient and explain everything every question in great detail.

They don't bother me. I have never had a claim so its very hard to say something I like about them.

The only negative thing is their website for home insurance, it just shows what You have and when You've paid. Some basic explanations of the coverage. That's it - no quotes in there.

I do not like the price of the package. I want to be offered more for what I am paying. I also do not like their customer service support.

American Modern Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

They over good coverage at a decent rate and are much lower than most companies that I have contacted recently. Also, they do not change in rates for no reason at all. I do not appreciate when insurance companies change my premium for no apparent reason at all, especially when I've been with them for a while and have no claims.

Auto Owners Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they have low rates and have great coverage on what they cover. I also like that we were given the option to drop some things off our coverage that we didn't need to save money.

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

Overall I like State Farm, that is why I have been with them over 20 years. I appreciate their professionalism and honest with my questions and claim. I am happy with their plans and their discounts.

I like that our company provides plans for all of our insurance needs.

The claims process is very good. The customer center is very good. This what you get with a big and well known company.

The insurance rep is not helpful. The company should be offering ways to save money more often. They need to be more customer helpful.

I am at level three satisfaction because while they have completed the claims with a fair enough dollar amount it hasn't always been without some level of annoyance and slower than I would like. They are nice at our local office and I know they are not going out of their way to be troublesome, I feel like they may also be waiting on the home office and that causes delays.

I wish my rates were a bit lower, but all in all I can't complain because I have not found any other company that could give me lower rates than what I currently have now.

The premium is very competitive when compared to all other companies, I don't see much difference.

Giving fast customer services while transfer the amount in a timely manner

As stated previously I called them about busted pipes, they were very helpful over the phone. The process is very easy

I had an emergency situation where 2 pipes broke at my home. I called the customer service everything they alerted my local agent. They got in touch with me the next day.

I have never had a claim and prices do not go up very much

I like their site and I like their customer service. I am always leaving with a smile on my face. I am glad to work with them.

Overall I love my insurance company and would recommend it to everyone looking for insurance.

I don't hear from my agent at all unless he has something additional to sell. I don't like to be pushed toward additional products that I don't need. This has really only happened once. State Farm wasn't able to meet our needs for life insurance.

I have been insured through State Farm since I was 16, and as an adult, ever since I bought my first home. I have always found my agent and his office staff responsive and easy to work with. They always answer my questions and offer me the best rates. I like that I can combine my homeowners with my car insurance, etc. When I did file a claim - although it was an auto-related claim - I was extremely happy with the aid I received, and as such, this company has received my loyalty.

I have not had to use them but i know other people who said they paid their claims without and hassle. i have been with them for about 12 yeaars.

Compared to rates at other insurance companies, our rate is competitive although paying less would be ideal.

I like the company because they're easy to work with through the web and they came through when I needed my loan approved

I think that they could work on the technology piece. the website needs some updates.

I have no real base to compare my insurance with other companies' just because when I asked for a quote they gave me a really good deal so I picked them.

I have only used their customer service at State Farm a handful of times over the two decades I have had their insurance, but when I have used them they have been responsive and courteous.

The company's website is easily navigable and intuitive to use. They have a location finder for locating local offices and the contact information is easily accessible.

I like the low rates the company offers. They are a reputable national agency. I like the roadside service that the offer, they have paid for our car to be towed a few times.

The technology the company uses seems out of date, especially at the agent's office. The last time I went to their office the employees were still using the green and white monitors (although that was several years ago).

I've been with State Farm since 1999 when I bought the house and I changed my auto insurance with them afterward for a discount. I've been happily satisfied with them for 19 years with zero problems or issues.

The insurance company representative was professional, knowledgeable and kind. My insurance company is prompt and take care of their business without delay.

I have no real complaints about my current company. In fact, I can't even find things to nitpick about as of yet and I've been with them for a while now. I just hope they don't change upper management anytime soon or get the idea to try and start selling a bunch of junk to their customer base to increase their bottom dollar. I have been through that before.

I would prefer that the mobile app be a little better about being faster and contain more information that I need. I would prefer that my agent be easier to get a hold of, rather than having to talk to a 1-800 agent. I also dislike that it takes a lot of paperwork to file a claim.

The only thing I dislike about the company is their lack of promotional discounts or even just reaching out to customers, in general about anything to deal with the policy.

Overall I have zero complaints about my insurance company. They have never given me a problem with anything and have always been very accommodating.

Their fees aren't the cheapest, but that is the worst of having them for your coverage. Other than that, you will be pleasantly surprised at everything else they do and cover.

They are not as cheap as some of the other companies that exist out there, some companies have better rates.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company