Top Nebraska Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Nebraska homeowners insurance is roughly $1,226. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $429 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Nebraska Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 25.17
Farm Bureau -
Allstate 5.37
Progressive -
Geico -
Stillwater insurance Group -
Westfield Insurance -
Farmers Insurance 4.64
Nationwide 7.19
Travelers 2.8
Finance Insurance -
Safeco Insurance -
Liberty Mutual 3.94
Plummer Insurance -
Amica Mutual Insurance -
Black Ridge Bank -
National General -
Kemper -
Farmer's Insurance -
MetLife -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Kemper Home Insurance Reviews

They are inexpensive and they provide excellent service to me. That's a win compared to many other insurance agencies that I've worked with in the past.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Although I could probably save money if I bundled other insurance premiums with this company, I have trust that this company will take care of me if things go bad.

We are provided with a great agent that does very well at addressing any concerns we have. We have also been very satisfied with the amount of coverage we receive for the cost of our insurance.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they kept the rate they said they would keep, and that they discount our monthly service since we have auto insurance with them.

They act fast and provide a human touch to the insurance field. I have been satisfied in all instances of the claim process and will keep them for years to come.

I will keep them for a while because they have excellent rates, they have good customer service and their process is really easy. I think that's what they should offer, and they are a good company.

They are so large that sometimes it's hard to get in contact with who I need to. For example, I have to go through many options to reach a human

There really isn't anything I don't like about Progressive. Their prices are fair, their claim process is easy and quick and their representatives understand my concerns.

Their only bad point is that their phone lines can sometimes be busy, wait times are a bit much (5 mins or so) and their offices are not really close to my home (around 6 miles). However, none of that is really negative.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they are friendly and knowledgeable. I like that they are always there when we have questions or concerns. They don't bother us with lots of calls or emails about "how are you liking this or that, would you like to add change coverage, etc."

I dislike that they haven't changed our rate in over 5+ years. We have not had to file a home claim and the premium remains the same.

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews

I do not have a dislike for the company. The time I interacted was great. I do not think there is anything to dislike about travelers.

It is clunky, slow to load and has limited options compared to others.

Farm Bureau Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that it is more locally oriented and is a co-op. It is a national company, but with local divisions. I get to vote on directors, etc. Also, when I call, I'm talking to a local person usually, and not someone in another country who I can barely understand.

I like that they are friendly when I go in. I like that it is local to me so if I ever need to file a claim I can just drive over to them and sort it out.

I would suggest anyone use this insurance company. I feel like they truly care and have never had any issues out of them at all.

This is actually very hard for me to do. I can't think of anything they said or done that I dislike about the company. I'm just being honest.

We get insurance magazines from our insurance company that are interesting. We also get surveys from them for coverage updates. Also holiday cards and follow up letters are very nice to get.

I don't like the fact that the premiums are higher than what I was paying with my previous carrier, and the deductibles are also higher.

Farm Bureau's pricing is higher than other insurance companies that I have dealt with in the past. The company does not seem to be quite as technologically advanced as some.

I honestly cannot think of one bad thing to say about my insurance company. It's true that great.

I dislike the lack of online usage. They have a very limited site online and this makes it difficulty when I am trying to pay my bills online.

Stillwater insurance Group Home Insurance Reviews

Due to the rates and customer service offered, we are extremely satisfied. Thanks to a broker, they found Stillwater who accepted our application.

They are very responsive and get back to us immediately or within an acceptable amount of time for any inquires we have.

Their website is simple and easy to navigate. Whatever I need is easily found and the instructions on their site are very clear.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews


It is easy to use and the customer service has been good so far. They seem to be open a lot and have good hours to call during the evenings. Overall a very positive experience.

Customer service has always been helpful to me, every time I have contacted them for any issues.


Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

A few years ago I have some damage in my backyard and the company was extremely helpful and I loved how easy it was to solve my issue.

Good friendly people. Glad I have went with them after all these years. Hope to stay with them for a while.

We love the fact that it's a nationwide company, but our agents treat us like we are their only customers. They provide personalized service without any hassle and with a smile!

I am offered a great amount of coverage for the premium that I am paying. Customer service is excellent and I believe if I ever needed to file a claim the process would be very straight forward.

I wish they have special offers more often. As a loyal customer I would like to have more discounts and other benefits.

There is nothing that we dislike about our insurance company. If we disliked the company, we would not be giving them our money each month.

The major dislike is the fact that it isn’t the cheapest route that I could go. There are other companies where I could get the same coverage for less.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

I never had any issues, it was a simple process to add them as the carrier. Rates were low for a long time, even beating out when bundled with other products.

My new insurance company is quick to respond to me and handle my requests. On top of that, I am paying less for more coverage than I previously had.

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I couldn't compare it with other insurance companies since I haven't done any comparison recently,

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

If my rates haven't climbed so I high over the past year, I would be very happy with my company. I feel like a get a personal level of care from my local agent. I'm not dealing with a person I've never met. They have taken the time to get to know me and I'm willing to pay a bit more for that.

State Farm has been a great company for me. They have always answered my questions and never given me a hard time. I would highly recommend them.

I like that, when the time comes I can bundle all of my insurance with this company and have it all in one place, with one payment. I like the reliability of the company and the warm, kindness of my representative.

I became a customer of State Farm almost 20 years ago when I moved to Florida where my insurance at the time did not have coverage. State Farm was the cheapest I found and I am happy that they are such a well known and well-established company.

They have always been honest and clear with their communications

I like the feeling that I have coverage for my home and cars and my insurance company does that for me and addresses my needs.

I can deal with the mail the comes from them but I don't know if I will stay with them if I get another year of high rate jumps. The rates increases seem very substantial. I feel like asking them to cut their advertising budget to keep my rates low.

I have not found anything that I dislike about the company. They have always handled me with respect.

I have not had any altercations where I can claim to dislike anything just yet. Some of the mail or alerts are a little annoying, but other than that I am overall pretty satisfied.

I have never had any issues with State Farm. Their prices are great, their employees are knowledgeable and friendly and their billing process is simple.

Maybe a bit hands off until you need them. I don't feel like I personally know any of them.

I don't really dislike anything. They get a negative reputation around, which concerns me a bit. I worry that I'm missing something important.

Nothing readily comes to mind. But on further thought I would like to see the company automatically review the policies for me and give me discounts if applicable.

MetLife Home Insurance Reviews

Comparing to other companies MetLife company's home insurance premium amount is better. In other companies we need to pay more money.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company