Top Missouri Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Missouri homeowners insurance is roughly $1,199. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $419 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Missouri Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 25.77
14
Shelter -
6
Allstate 3.98
5
USAA 4.17
4
American Family 15.23
2
Safeco -
2
Columbia -
2
Progressive -
2
Travelers -
2
Geico -
2
Farmers Insurance 8.07
2
Armed Forces Insurance -
2
Liberty Mutual 8.93
2
AAA -
1
Alfa Insurance -
1

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

American Family Home Insurance Reviews


I have complete confidence in American Family Insurance. Their prices are very reasonable and their services are above average as for the Insurance industry. We are very happy with the company.

I really can not think of something I dislike about American Family Insurance. We bundled our insurance and they give us peace of mind at great prices.

Safeco Home Insurance Reviews


I like the fast communication I have with the staff overall. They respond to emails or phone calls whenever I have a question or need to make a change.

They send confusing correspondence that does not always match my bill. That may be headquartered sending our automatically generated mail so it is not a big deal.

Columbia Home Insurance Reviews


I give it a 4 because the price is so high, but I guess it is high everywhere. Insurance is just high period.

Like I said before, I haven't had any dealings with them over claims, thankfully. The price is a bit high in my opinion. I deal directly with my sister so I don't deal with their customer service.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews


I like that the premium is cheaper than most reputable insurance companies I really have no interaction with them other than that

I can't say that I dislike the company because I have never really had to have any interaction with them other than paying my bill

Shelter Home Insurance Reviews


I'm satisfied with the coverage and the people that I have to deal with. Everyone there is always very nice and takes time to make sure everything is going well. I like that I can always talk to someone too.

They are a great company. Great deals when you bundle everything up. Much cheaper than their competitors. They are also local.

I like how they always communicate with me really well and let me know what is going on. It's also nice that they don't try to jerk me around if I file a claim and things go like they should, things like that do make me like the company.

I feel like my rate is a bit high. I feel like I could switch and save some money so that is always on my mind. I don't like to overpay for anything even of the service is pretty good.

There's nothing that I really dislike about the company. They are cheaper than the others. They are local compared to others. They are friendlier than the others.

I know some people who pay less for their premium than I do. I don't like that too much and I know that when I filed a claim it took it a bit longer than I'd like for it to be settled so some issues with that.

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews


I like the financial stability and accessibility of the company. They are established and known in the marketplace. The coverage fits my needs.

They sometimes subcontract out the claims work to 3rd parties. The quality is hard to keep a handle on with a subcontractor. When there are a lot of regional claims, they can get overloaded and slowed down.

USAA Home Insurance Reviews


The company is wonderful. Their banking, investing, home, auto, and life insurance is combined to simplify things. They are friendly and take care of their customers.

Their website is easy to use and makes tracking claims and policy information very simple and easy. Communications we do get are stored so they can be reviewed at a later time.

There really is not anything that I dislike about the company. They have been exceptional in all of their services to us. We never even have a long phone wait.

We've been treated very poorly, and they clearly have no interest in actually honoring the contract they have with their customers. We plan to cancel our policy and never work with this provider again in the future.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews


This company is great. I'm very satisfied with them, that's why I haven't changed insurance companies in years. I plan to keep this company for a while now.

There is nothing that I don't like about this insurance company. I have never had a negative experience with this insurance company.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews


I like the level of customer service provided and the way they keep me informed. I like the way they try to make things as user friendly as possible for their customers.

I would like to see further steps to increase their customer service representatives, because wait times on phone calls can be a bit ridiculous. I also would like to see more incentives for saving money, perhaps a discount for being a long-term customer or further bundling discounts that make it truly worth utilizing.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews


They are prompt, polite, and a great value. They've really gone above and beyond for me in the past, beyond what I expected from an insurance company.

Allstate has been reliable for all the years I have used them with all the services, and they always keep me informed about any applicable discounts and whatnot.

I don't think there's anything I dislike about the company, except maybe the fact that I have to deal with the hassle of insurance at all. That's not really on them, though.

Obviously, it is always possible to get lower rates. I often hear of peers who pay much lower rates, so I often wonder if I could get lower rates by switching.

Just don't like my premium amount.

Armed Forces Insurance Home Insurance Reviews


The service of the company is very good, and my friends have the high opinion of the company.

What I dislike is that the premium is comparatively higher and they charge heavily for late payment.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews


I like how they are nationwide, so I don't have to worry about reliability and locality. There are agents all over the country.

I dislike the constant mail, and that the premiums and deductibles keep going up, even though I haven't filed a claim.

AAA Home Insurance Reviews


There is really nothing I dislike about the actual company. I do dislike insurance overall because it is so expensive and such a sham.

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews


they are a well working company that does the necessary and doesn't require higher purchases

The are friendly and always so helpful. The stay in constant communication and get things done in a professional and respectable manner.

It's a solid company that offered me the best rate on my house that didn't seem like a shady company.

The company is very reliable, understanding, the rates are reasonable and very informative about the coverage of the type of insurance you are inquiring about

Personal service at the local level. I have not contacted the home office.

Overall, I like the friendliness of the staff and how helpful they are when I have had to file an auto insurance claim. I have been offered a great discount on all of my insurance through them/

I am pretty satisfied with my insurance company. I will say that if we got better rates somewhere else we are not married to our company. We usually look for the best rates and the best premiums and go with that. If at some point in the future we find someone who will do anything to help us out then we may stick with them despite being a tad more expensive, but at this time in our lives we are more concerned about cost.

I really don't dislike anything about them they are always helpful and nice maybe insist have to pay my premiums lol but that is not their fault

the wait time when calling in is very long and could be a bit shorter

I just don't agree with some of the rates offered to me. In some cases involving changing vehicles, I was sure my insurance would be cheaper. And with the bundle home and auto discount, I don't really see much of a discount.

it takes a long time to get a person on the phone that can actually answer a question.

During my divorce, no parties were to be removed or allowed to change anything on the policy. They allowed my ex to remove his name in violation.

The only issue I have had with the company was with one of their claims reps when I was in an auto accident. The agent whom I spoke with on the phone actually implied that I had caused the damage myself. I did get it worked out with the insurance company

The only bad thing I have to say about my insurance company is that it is very large and sometimes I feel that it is not personal enough for my liking, but on the other hand there is always someone who can answer a question that I have.

Alfa Insurance Home Insurance Reviews


There is nothing I dislike about this company, great customer service, great premiums, fast response time to claims I can't find a company that has been as good to me as them.


Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company