Top Indiana Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Indiana homeowners insurance is roughly $944. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $330 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Indiana Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 26.94
Erie Insurance 5.62
Allstate 7.55
American Family 6.09
Progressive -
Geico -
Farmers Insurance 2.75
Auto Owners -
Nationwide -
Liberty Mutual 7.54

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

American Family Home Insurance Reviews

I do like that when you walk into their office they seem very friendly and accommodating. They all have smiles on their faces and they exude a hometown-like atmosphere.

They are a very big company. Sometimes seeing all their commercials on television makes you wonder where the money you pay for your policy is going.

AAA Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they are helpful and reliable. They are very quick dealing with issues and their customer service is excellent.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

I dislike pretty much everything. First, their prices are inflated. Second, they have a horrible relationship with customers. When I called for help 5 years ago after our agent was fired, I was clueless and they didn't help me any.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

The company is forward looking and cares about its customer. I think that's very important for an insurance company (second home in the state). I choose a different insurer from GEICO because I want diversion.

I don't like that their customer service is average at best and varies from staff to staff. The training should be better.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

I like having all my insurance bundled together. I also like being covered by a reputable company that has been around for many years.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews

I have yet to see how this goes, cause I don't want my home to be damaged in anyway, so I wish I'd never use their insurance, but anything could happen, for example, my house got strike by meteorite, then I'll ask them for a claim.

We have to say we do not have much to dislike about this company. We have only had good experience with this company at this time. We have had no problems with getting a good service.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they will even call you to make sure that you're doing ok throughout the process. They seemed very interested in our thoughts.

Overall, I like how Allstate does business. I have had positive interactions with them and enjoy having them as my house insurance company. I do not have to worry about submitting a claim.

I am completely satisfied thus far. I know some people have had bad experiences, but I guess it is always good and bad, and thankfully I've only good things to say.

I wish they had more discounts and my bill would stop going up every year. I always with j could pay with a check instead of bank drafts.

A little pricey maybe. But Well worth it, with all that they provide to you and the assurance that they will be there for you, it's priceless.

Erie Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I am very satisfied with what I pay for the coverage and peace of mind I receive. I would not care to go anywhere else anytime soon. They have always been there for me when needed.

It seems like the average insurance company, I also do my car insurance there and I get nice discounts.

It's hard to get in contact with my agent but otherwise, it's okay and I don't have a problem with the company as a whole

There is nothing that I dislike about the company. They have always been reliable with me and always ask what they can do to make my experience better.

They are not located in the town I live now, they are located where I used to live. I like to support local places, and essentially this is local and small town.

Mostly my agent that works for the company rather than the company itself.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that when a problem arises my insurance covers it. I have never been liable for a large bill. I also love that they are always reachable.

I feel like it's an honestly a company who puts my insurance needs first, gives me a fair rate and never treats me like I'm just another dollar sign.

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

They are reasonably priced, great customer service.

State Farm is transparent about all the costs of home insurance. They are willing to work with me and they make my life simplified by having a convenient web portal and by clearly keeping me updated on my insurance coverage via email.

It is a solid company that is straightforward and honest but knows their value and is not afraid to charge their customers for that value.

Overall highly satisfied. Always there when needed, provide great products that we use, reasonably priced, and always there when we need them.

I like that I can speak with my agent directly. I like that I trust the company to pay if I have an issue. I like having 24/7 service.

I love the ease of signing up for my policy and how easy it is to ask questions and receive answers.

I like my agent more than the company. My agent has been really good and helpful. He has always taken my call or called me back in a very short time frame.

I like that they are loyal to their customers. Even if you were not the cause of an accident they will help as a go-between with you and the other company. They don't allow other companies to take advantage of their customers.

There isn't anything that I dislike honestly

The only thing that I dislike is the high price of premiums. I think this will hold true with any home insurance company, or at least the ones I've looked at, so it's not a major complaint. The amount of coverage I get and the ease of use is well worth the price in my mind.

The price is high and sometimes it feels like you are just paying the company to get more money. I think that eventually, I will look for cheaper premiums.

The only thing I dislike is there website and the lack of features they have. If I want to update any info or look up policy information, I have to call.

The one thing that I dislike about the company is they have weird office hours

They seem to be getting greedy and raising rates just to raise it. There is no rhyme or reason why my rates raise so much from year to year. I've only made one claim in 10 years, I pay on time, and I'm in a low-risk area. I just don't get it.

I really don't dislike the company. They have always been helpful and taken care of me. If I ever need help they are always there to help.

Auto Owners Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that they are efficient and have some of the lowest insurance policy rates around. I like that I can use my local insurance agency, which is only a block away, instead of having to do everything online or drive to another town in my rural area to get insurance.

The only thing I dislike about the insurance company in general is that they are somewhat impersonal when dealing with the company itself and the premium is rather high, but compared to other companies, I like this company.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company