Top Indiana Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Indiana homeowners insurance is roughly $944. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $330 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Indiana Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 26.94
Allstate 7.55
Geico -
Erie Insurance 5.62
Auto Owners -
Progressive -
Liberty Mutual 7.54
Farmer's Insurance -
American Family 6.09
Travelers 2.63
Nationwide -
Grange Insurance -
Amica Mutual Insurance -
Farmers Insurance 2.75
MetLife -
Farm Bureau -
Auto Owners Insurance -
National General -
Universal Property and Casualty -
Alfa Insurance -
Electric Insurance -
Synergy Insurance Group -
Lenox Mutual Insurance -
Pekin Insurance -
Safeco Insurance -
Country Financial -
USAA 2.8
American Modern Insurance -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

National General Home Insurance Reviews

I don't really dislike this company as they are always helpful. I haven't found a reason to yet dislike them.

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews

I think travelers insurance is a stable company which will payout if a claim has to be issued. There is a local office which I like having around. There a cheaper companies but the value we get is worth the little extra.

Travelers has a very easy to use APP. It is easy to find the information or menu that I need. It is not hidden under category like some other apps.

The only concern that I have is they need more discounts for seniors and special rates for persons who have not made any claims I over 15 years

Grange Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Grange is okay the problem with customer service is that a lot of it is outsourced from India and I cannot understand a lot of what they are saying

Overall, the only thing I don't like is their website doesn't let me access my policy details. I have to dig through my personal paper files to review my coverages.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews

I have yet to see how this goes, cause I don't want my home to be damaged in anyway, so I wish I'd never use their insurance, but anything could happen, for example, my house got strike by meteorite, then I'll ask them for a claim.

Our insurance agency calls us to let us know a knew coverage is available and because they know us instead of just being a number to them they call us to ask if we'd like something added when they think it might interest us. We are very satisfied with their communication.

Large corporation. I know people who work for them and they are treated somewhat poorly unless they are in sales.

Great, funny commercials, customer service. Claims are speedy and very responsive. Any time I have called them, they immediately answer.

I disliked that after I had purchased my policy, I was contacted frequently by my local office asking me to come in and talk about other insurance options, even though I had told them I was already covered by other companies.

Already gave satisfactory answers with previous questions that covered the same subject. I like the company's service and it is cheap.

We have to say we do not have much to dislike about this company. We have only had good experience with this company at this time. We have had no problems with getting a good service.

In general I really like this insurance company and I am very happy to be affiliated with them at this time in life

Universal Property and Casualty Home Insurance Reviews

I found Universal at a time when I was disgusted with home insurance. Universal turned out to be a genuine company who didn't try to oversell me insurance. It is a company that I can depend on and that I know will cover me for exactly what I need.

Erie Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

It's hard to get in contact with my agent but otherwise, it's okay and I don't have a problem with the company as a whole

I am very satisfied with what I pay for the coverage and peace of mind I receive. I would not care to go anywhere else anytime soon. They have always been there for me when needed.

It seems like the average insurance company, I also do my car insurance there and I get nice discounts.

Mostly my agent that works for the company rather than the company itself.

Overall we are satisfied with the insurance company. Our rates have actually decreased, the website is decent and overall customer service is ok. They keep us updated as to any policy changes and sometimes send out a newsletter.

Again, I wish they would all you to do more online instead of through mail or fax. It seems like they need to update their technology to get with the times.

There is nothing that I dislike about the company. They have always been reliable with me and always ask what they can do to make my experience better.

They are not located in the town I live now, they are located where I used to live. I like to support local places, and essentially this is local and small town.

Alfa Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The thing that I like the most is the reputation. They really do seem like a trustworthy company that cares about the community. I wouldn't swap because of their great name in this community.

Electric Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like it for its delivery with the clients, its responsibility and dedication at the moment of making the insurance contract ... agreeing good terms for both

Amica Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like this company because of providing more coverage on damages.

During the time of approval and claim process they making little later.

Synergy Insurance Group Home Insurance Reviews

The rate is decent for the company. I haven't had to contact them for anything major, so I have had no problems in communicating. I have never had to file a claim.

Lenox Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The company could have been more professional and understanding of our situation. We felt like we were just another number to them and didn't feel like they cared about our situation.

Pekin Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The premium is probably the best thing so far. I have not filed a claim so I can't speak to that process. This company was cheaper for the same coverage

Safeco Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

It was a pain getting in contact with them. They were not as responsive as they should have been. The insurance payments seemed to go up inordinately in price after the incident

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I think that I have seen other plan that are a bit better than the one I have because I have spoken to family members with different plans that are cheaper and cover more.

I know that insurance can be a bit pricey and often overspend. I have a good policy that covers me with almost anything.

I don't have anything specific I dislike about them as I haven't had that much experience with them yet. I'm hoping there won't be much to dislike.

While I am satisfied with my company, I wonder if I can get the same level of service at a cheaper cost - I see ads that promise a lower premium and would like to lower my costs.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

I like having all my insurance bundled together. I also like being covered by a reputable company that has been around for many years.

The website of the company looks very much professional as well as attractive. The navigation and the interface of the website is simple.

Liberty Mutual is a great company that has a lot of benefits to people that do not need to make claims often. They have explained my plan in detail.

I like that Liberty Mutual was pretty easy to get homeowners and auto insurance bundled together. I have the low car and house insurance because of this. This was partly due to the fact that I have a credit union account with one of their partners so I was able to save money. The also had the lowest rates compared to their competitors.

Since I bought the house in 2007, my premium has gone up 40%, even though I have not made a single claim, and I have made on-time payments.

Auto Owners Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that they are efficient and have some of the lowest insurance policy rates around. I like that I can use my local insurance agency, which is only a block away, instead of having to do everything online or drive to another town in my rural area to get insurance.

Is outdated, I actually prefer not to go to their website and deal with them on the phone. I have not tried the app yet.

I have not had any major interaction with my insurance people about my house insurance in the last year or so.

On an claim I filed a couple of years ago it took Owners about twenty four hours to respond to me, which felt a bit longer than I should've had to wait but other than that they have been pretty prompt in responding to me.

The only thing I dislike about the insurance company in general is that they are somewhat impersonal when dealing with the company itself and the premium is rather high, but compared to other companies, I like this company.

The company has a fairly boiler plate website with only limited information about the company. There is no way to interact with my policy through it. They do not have a mobile app.

Country Financial Home Insurance Reviews

They are everything anyone could ask for out of an insurance company. After purchasing my new home in a different state i was mortified about having to move to another company but to my relief i was able to stay with them. Any issues or problems are always quickly resolved and they are always polite and courteous.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

I like the easy access to services. I also like the discounts I get for having my insurance there. I love the fact that I can go to any office and get help.

I had a claim for property damage from a construction company working next door that damaged my house. My insurance agents kept giving me the run around for a year. Until I filed a claim with the Department of Insurance and received my money a week later.

I dislike pretty much everything. First, their prices are inflated. Second, they have a horrible relationship with customers. When I called for help 5 years ago after our agent was fired, I was clueless and they didn't help me any.

USAA Home Insurance Reviews


Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they will even call you to make sure that you're doing ok throughout the process. They seemed very interested in our thoughts.

Overall, I like how Allstate does business. I have had positive interactions with them and enjoy having them as my house insurance company. I do not have to worry about submitting a claim.

I am completely satisfied thus far. I know some people have had bad experiences, but I guess it is always good and bad, and thankfully I've only good things to say.

I think that this company charges a premium that is a bit higher as compared to other companies.

I didn't shop around for insurance at the time. I am sure that I might be able to find an insurance cheaper elsewhere, however, I don't want to deal with the hassle

They always answer when I call them, and have reached out to me on many occasions through email and text about different things such as birthdays.

I like that they offer pretty comprehensive insurance, which includes bundling discounts, at a price that I think is competitive among insurance companies with a good reputation. I may switch if my rates go up but right now I'm very happy.

The company is detailed, organized and respectable and I never had any problems concerning the customer service and the time frame when it comes to discussing my policy.

I think its more about the service that I receive from my agent as opposed to just saying I like the company. The service has made the difference in tailoring a policy to my need. Finding out what is the best way to maximize coverage and not spending too much money either.

Easy to deal with and very responsive. The people at the agency are friendly and helpful and in the few instances where I have had to file claims for auto and deal with the corporate office, they have been good too.

The customer service is great and all representatives we have dealt with are friendly and helpful. If we need to call several times they are always willing to help and return calls quickly.

I like that I can access my policy and see my payments online. I also like that I can easily find my agent's contact information, and send an email if I have a question.

I liked to recommend to my friends and colleagues as they are in the field long time.

I appreciate the helpfulness of the insurance agent and his office staff when I call to request information. They are always very friendly and take care of my concerns. I also feel that my premiums are reasonable, though they may not be the lowest. I like the coverage they offer, though it's not perfect.

I wish they had more discounts and my bill would stop going up every year. I always with j could pay with a check instead of bank drafts.

Always room to decrease premium, no interaction or bonuses for being a loyal customer. The communication tactics used by the company are very robotic and targeted towards the entire mass instead of personally addressed.

I like the slogan. I also like that it's pretty straightforward and easy to apply and get the insurance and have it directly paid from your bank account.

A little pricey maybe. But Well worth it, with all that they provide to you and the assurance that they will be there for you, it's priceless.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that when a problem arises my insurance covers it. I have never been liable for a large bill. I also love that they are always reachable.

I feel like it's an honestly a company who puts my insurance needs first, gives me a fair rate and never treats me like I'm just another dollar sign.

MetLife Home Insurance Reviews

It is not the interaction but the lack thereof. I don't hear anything from them unless there is an issue or premium renewal.

Last year I added an Auto to my policy and they made it a very easy process for me.

American Family Home Insurance Reviews

I do like that when you walk into their office they seem very friendly and accommodating. They all have smiles on their faces and they exude a hometown-like atmosphere.

They are a very big company. Sometimes seeing all their commercials on television makes you wonder where the money you pay for your policy is going.

I think the website and the mobile app are both very easy to use. They are both easy to navigate and are easily understood.

I think the company is very well run. I think they take a lot of pride in helping people and it really shows in how they treat their customers.

AAA Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they are helpful and reliable. They are very quick dealing with issues and their customer service is excellent.

I like that I get a discount when having my home and car insured through them and that the payments are paid through my escrow account.

Customer service at AAA is pretty good. I have no issues getting a human on the phone to talk to and the agents are responsible and responsive. The agents also follow through and try to help you.

I like the website because it has all the information I need, such as policy detail, payment information, payment history, and I can also print out my insurance information.

I like the company because the prices are competitive with other companies. The agents are responsive and I can get someone on the phone that I can talk to. AAA also has a lot of offices around where I live, so I can talk to someone in person if I want to.

We can usually get accurate info via phone, but occasionally we need to go into the office to be certain of the information. It's just a quick trip down the street.

The main thing I like is the cost. If it would not have so much cheaper I would not have switched companies, but it was so and so far so good. I would definitely recommend to a friend.

Best rates around for home and auto, bundling is a nice feature.

I sure I can find a lower rate with another company and the insurance agent I have is trash in my opinion.

They provide a good service for the money, and they don't get all up in your face or up in your business. They stay in the shadows.

I have no dislikes ths far. We have only been with them about 8 months but so far so good

Very clunky and not at all user-friendly. Many times the site chokes and won't accept my payment.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

The company is forward looking and cares about its customer. I think that's very important for an insurance company (second home in the state). I choose a different insurer from GEICO because I want diversion.

Very compeitive rates and willing to bundle home and auto insurance. Was much cheaper then comptitor

It gives me a bundle discount and I think I am saving money. I am not sure if there might be a better deal out there somewhere. I also like that it's a well-known company and not a place that is likely to screw you over.

Overall I like the structure of the company website and their multi-policy discount. It is easy to find information about the coverage and proof of insurance on the website.

Their customer service representatives are very responsive and easy to work with.

I don't like that their customer service is average at best and varies from staff to staff. The training should be better.

Farm Bureau Home Insurance Reviews

The insurance is expensive. They will not insure me for auto coverage since I have a DUI therefore I cannot get a multiple discount

It is dependable. It is personable, They have been in business a long time. It is close to where I live.

American Modern Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

it is hard to find companies around here that offer insurance for mobile homes, so they seem average compared to what is offered

Auto Owners Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

it is a good company with a good reputation. when I needed it paid the damage from the storm. I don't like to pay for insurance but when I need it to be there for me it has been.

The fact that we had to put a fence around our pool even when living in the country and the fact that the fence only had to be 4ft which is shorter than the pool. I wish we could have done a pool alarm or talked to them about a provision.

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

They are reasonably priced, great customer service.

State Farm is transparent about all the costs of home insurance. They are willing to work with me and they make my life simplified by having a convenient web portal and by clearly keeping me updated on my insurance coverage via email.

It is a solid company that is straightforward and honest but knows their value and is not afraid to charge their customers for that value.

Overall highly satisfied. Always there when needed, provide great products that we use, reasonably priced, and always there when we need them.

I like that I can speak with my agent directly. I like that I trust the company to pay if I have an issue. I like having 24/7 service.

I love the ease of signing up for my policy and how easy it is to ask questions and receive answers.

I like that they are loyal to their customers. Even if you were not the cause of an accident they will help as a go-between with you and the other company. They don't allow other companies to take advantage of their customers.

I like my agent more than the company. My agent has been really good and helpful. He has always taken my call or called me back in a very short time frame.

They seem to be getting greedy and raising rates just to raise it. There is no rhyme or reason why my rates raise so much from year to year. I've only made one claim in 10 years, I pay on time, and I'm in a low-risk area. I just don't get it.

I really do not know how the customer service would be. Whenever I have an issue I talk to my agent. I have never had to make a claim so I'm unsure how customer service would be to work with.

the company seems to be okay as in they did what they are supposed to do as in fix my house when something goes wrong.

I like that when I am speaking with a representative, I feel like my questions and issues are important to the company. I don't feel like just a number. This is why I choose to keep my business here.

I think the insurance company is pretty good overall. I think they decent service and I have had good meetings with them in the past.

There is not anything that I can think of at the moment that we dislike about State Farm. One of the best locally run companies we have come by.

I appreciate that State Farm is reliable and relatively inexpensive for my family. I feel safe with State Farm knowing they can be trusted and my home, car, and family are protected and insured under them.

I'm happy with the service but not so happy with the cost. But, I guess you get what you pay for.

The way they dealt with my claim seemed very unprofessional, and they could have avoided talking to me entirely if they just communicated with the mortgage lender in the first place.

My insurance company is a top-notch organization. This organization has helped me with auto insurance and home/renters insurance for nearly 15 years and have always been there to assist me when making changes to coverage, adding new coverage, or even stopping coverage. This allowed me to have a quick turnaround when dealing with the removal of vehicles and moving.

We know who they are by name and they are always good at pointing out details that we did not know. We have bundled up many services with them. This is a huge saving.

I like that I can get a discount for having multiple policies and that the office is close to my work so I can stop by whenever.

State Farm is a friendly and prompt company. They value the customer and treat them like they are always right. This is the old time feel that I really love in a modern age. It makes me feel like a man again.

The only thing that I dislike is the high price of premiums. I think this will hold true with any home insurance company, or at least the ones I've looked at, so it's not a major complaint. The amount of coverage I get and the ease of use is well worth the price in my mind.

The price is high and sometimes it feels like you are just paying the company to get more money. I think that eventually, I will look for cheaper premiums.

There isn't anything that I dislike honestly

I don't even know why we have home owners insurance. it just penalizes us and drains our bank account .

The only thing I dislike is there website and the lack of features they have. If I want to update any info or look up policy information, I have to call.

The one thing that I dislike about the company is they have weird office hours

I really don't dislike the company. They have always been helpful and taken care of me. If I ever need help they are always there to help.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company