Top Florida Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Florida homeowners insurance is roughly $2,055. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $719 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Florida Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
State Farm 6.6
USAA 4.34
Allstate -
Citizens Property Insurance -
Homeowners Choice -
Safeco -
Florida 1st Insurance -
Travelers -
Geico -
People's Trust Insurance -
Homeowner's Choice -
Safe Point -
Universal Property & Casualty -
Florida Farm Bureau Insurance -
St. Johns Insurance -
Liberty Mutual -
Assurant Specialty Property -
Security First -
Gulfstream Property and Casualty Insurance Company -
MetLife -
Security First Home Insurance -
Progressive 3.54
Farmers Insurance -
Farmer's Insurance -
Nationwide -
Stillwater insurance Group -
Frontline Insurance -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Homeowners Choice Home Insurance Reviews

I like that they are accessible and generally pretty helpful. I think that they do what they need to, but that's it. It's not a great relationship but it works

I would like them to have greater resources and reserves. I worry that at the time of an event they will have a hard time paying out

Safeco Home Insurance Reviews

I don't know a lot about home insurance, so it's hard to know how good of a job they are doing. But they did a fair job with our claim and gave us a good deal to begin the policy, so overall I am moderately satisfied.

Overall I am moderately satisfied. Safeco seems to really want my business and gave me a military discount. I don't plan on replacing them.

Florida 1st Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The companies’ premiums are reasonable. I like that I can bundle my auto. I like that they are quick to respond when filing a claim.

I think the company needs to work more on their communication skills with the homeowner. I don't like that the insurance companies website is difficult to navigate

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews

Responsive. Easy communication through phone calls. The Website is usually up.

But the price is a little too high. In particular considering I am bundling with automobile policies and should receive a discount. On the contrary, the price for home insurance is actually higher than buying it alone somewhere else. The bundle discount is a total illusion.

SYNERGY Home Insurance Reviews

I like the fact that they hardly bother me. I don't get junk mail from them often. If I need to reach them, I'm sure it would be painless.

Since I have not had to deal with them I can't say anything is wrong. I dislike insurance companies in general, but so far so good with this one.

I dislike insurance companies in general, but so far so good with this one. I think that companies drop you the minute you need them, which is basically a scam.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews

I am genuinely happy with the overall coverage that I have. I also can't put a price on how comfortable I feel with the company and with how at ease they allow me to feel in knowing that they have my back if something in my house goes wrong.

The only thing I dislike about the company is the insurance prices. I do wish they were a little less. Especially with people like me who have been with the company for as long as I have been. I also wish that the information was more easily accessible on the company website.

Universal Property & Casualty Home Insurance Reviews

This company, as well as other insurance companies are careless. They just want their payment, nothing else.

I really dislike this company, so next year I am going to change my insurance company.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

The only thing I dislike is that it can take time to communicate.

St. Johns Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

St John's is a decent company to work with, they didn't low ball us on repairs and the response time was reasonable. The adjusters they sent were also very professional.

The only thing I dislike is the fact that while you are waiting to hear back from the company, that there are no status updates and no one you can contact, aside from calling customer service and going through the whole thing over again.

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

What I like most about Farmers is the people. The agents and claims representatives have been attentive and proactive.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

They were much cheaper overall when I initially switched to them years ago.

I really don't have anything I dislike about them.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

it is really good

USAA Home Insurance Reviews

We have an awesome insurance company. I would recommend this company to many people. They are one of the easiest insurers I have ever had to deal with.

The only problem I have had with the company is that the premiums keep on going up every time that I renew. Another wise I am very happy with the company that I have for insurance.

Would be nice to have a physical branch somewhere nearby. Only have a presence in Texas. Sometimes would be nice to talk face to face with someone

Good company overall. Site is easy to navigate and easy to retrieve needed information. Company representatives are available when needed. Premium could always be cheaper

Good company overall. Site is easy to navigate and easy to retrieve needed information. Company reps are available online when needed.

The premium is extremely competitive because USAA is a credit union effectively and the membership is restricted to service members and their families. The premiums are always either the least expensive or 2nd least.

USAA's customer service is well known in the industry for being the best. They really respect prior military and their family online. It is a completely different planet from most customer service experiences that you will find world-wide.

App is great because USAA doesn't have branches so the app is the primary way I get things done from transfers, to deposits to paying bills. Use the Android version.

Like most companies in general, regardless of the industry, it is the wait time while on hold when calling them. Nor can I stand the stupid elevator music they play.

I don't really dislike anything about the company except that there online platform is not so great. They could really use an update. It just isn't user friendly or easy to figure out how to pay the bill.

Security First Home Insurance Reviews

My agent as mentioned already, price, ease and reaction time plus everything else I already started I'm all above previous questions.

The only complaint so far is the amount of depreciation on my claim and only being able to recover it after I am invoiced.

Stillwater insurance Group Home Insurance Reviews

So far, their customer service appears to be good. They are able to answer any questions we have and are extremely helpful.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

I think they are a very good company, very reputable. They make sure that their clients are taken care of and they try to help in any way they can.

The website is modern, well thought out and easy to use. I like the menu on the side with bullet points

The app is very convenient. It is easy to navigate and has everything available that I need to do such as pay my bill.

I haven't really found anything that I dislike much about the company. They have always been good to me since I started with them.

How nice of coverage this insurance provides for so many things keeping me safe at all times .Thank you

I like everything about this company and they are user friendly

Little bit confusion on selecting the options and it takes so many times to wait

ASI Home Insurance Reviews

I had a water damage claim and was serviced immediately with a claim rep, a visit to inspect the damage, a damage mitigation company was hired and scheduled and I had a check in the mail in a few days. BTW, expecting my policy premium to go up the next year and it actually went down a few dollars.

I cannot really say anything bad about the company as I have had no bad experiences with them. The rates are reasonable and they were there when we needed them with no issue on anything at all during the entire claims process. I guess I cannot answer the question as you asked it. I hope this will suffice.

Safe Point Home Insurance Reviews

The only thing I like about this insurance company is that they agreed to write the insurance policy for us. Most major insurance companies refuse to insure properties in Florida and even fewer would insure our particular property.

The premium we pay for our policy is ridiculous. Additionally, the deductible for hurricane damage (which is the most likely damage situation in this area) is unaffordable despite being the lowest the company offers. The company also excludes damage to our fence and most other things that are likely to need repairs.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

I like how easy it was to get the quote and purchase the policy online. I love the app and all the things I can do with it. I like the discounts I received because I bundled my home and auto.

I really haven't had any bad experiences or dislikes thus far.

Citizens Property Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

There really isn't much too actually like about Citizens. The only good thing they have going for them is that they're the only company that will ensure our house. Other than that, their rating is pretty awful.

I would have to say that I am satisfied with the customer service. I am also satisfied with the billing and how the bill is easy to read and uncomplicated. I also know that if I want other services, State Farm is there to provide me with a variety of options (life insurance, mortgage etc.).

The company was there when I needed to find a new insurance company after my insurance company decided to bail on the state of Florida. I appreciated Citizens being available.

I have to say I have no dislikes for this company. My parents have used State Farm there whole life and have great relationships with the owners and customer service reps.

Have no reason so far to either like to dislike the company. They have always sent me to update letters and other information promptly when needed.

An incredibly expensive policy with a high deductible. However, they are the only insurance company that will cover us because of the age of our house. It's an awful monopoly and we feel trapped having no other choices

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

I have called and done all my business in person and the customer service is great. They will come to my home and I can come there and speak to someone without an appointment.

Overall I am satisfied with my insurance company. If I need them they are there. My agent keeps me up to date, and makes sure I have ample coverage for my life.

I have never looked up the coverages to other companies before when I bought my house I went the coverage that my real estate agent advised.

The website is easy to use, the mobile app makes me sign in every time it won't save my information.

I like that I can view all of my plans from the same site login and that it is easy to use.

We have only contacted them with questions. And additionally they have not contacted us, which is how I think it should be.

The website is very good with every detail what we want to see regularly is in the home page and so we can get it easily and the process for making online payment is also very smooth and securitized

When my pipes busted and they couldn't help with either. These things were not covered.

They are not good in English, most of time, I have to wait until I get the right person to have conversation with me.

I like that it is easy to navigate and you can check your account information and contact State Farm from the app. I think the app is also aesthetically pleasing

The website looks very much attractive. I also like the navigation of the website as it is very much simple and easy.

Since I have been a loyal customer I receive a lot of discounts. I don't think I would get these same discounts if I switched companies.

This is safer and better option than the other insurance companies. We can trust them completely as there are millions of satisfied customers all throughout.

I have no dislikes about this company and that is why I have been with them for over 20 years.

Frontline Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I have had no negative experiences with the company. The only improvement I would look for would be to more clearly list their insurance industry financial rating on their website. I had to dig through a third party site for that information.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company