Top Colorado Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Colorado homeowners insurance is roughly $1,273. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $445 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Colorado Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
USAA 10.72
State Farm 20.63
Allstate 9.99
American Family 9.83
Safeco -
Nationwide 2.3
Progressive -
Geico -
Farmer's Insurance -
Liberty Mutual 9.13
Amica -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

American Family Home Insurance Reviews

We have been with the company a long time and have always received prompt service. One agent even called us to see how our move to another town went.

The only thing I have been unhappy with was that when our agent retired, his replacement did not last long, but the company quickly assigned us another agent.

Safeco Home Insurance Reviews

They are national and well respected. The company is big enough to not go under so I am glad to have its stability. I like that they have a brick and mortar presence in my community.

I do apologize, but I don't have a specific grievance with the company. They are professional, courteous and don't give my wife or I any troubles.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

This company is an overall good company with both homeowners insurance and car insurance. They take their time and assist you with any problems and concerns and they make sure that you are covered any your claims are taken seriously

There is nothing that I really do not dislike. have not run into any problems with them with billing, customer service, nor my claims. This is a good company

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

I just like everything about the company overall. I get a cheap price, great support, and fantastic protection. I know if anything ever happens I will be covered and treated respectfully.

I can't think of anything I dislike about them. I mean sure it could be even cheaper, but they are already the cheapest I found around me, so why would they lose money for no reason?

USAA Home Insurance Reviews

Usaa is trustworthy and ethical. 2 things that aren't often found in business. I made sure when my children were born that they got usaa numbers of their own so they'd be able to use the services for life. I think that speaks volumes.

USaa takes care of military and their family they have a great attitude always help always kind

I am satisfied because they are attentive. I love the multi-policy discounts. I love the discount for being a service member. I love the fact that they only service the military community.

There's not much i can say about not liking. I love them and will stay with them for life!

the only complaint I have is the change in cost from state to state

I really have never found anything I don't like about this company. I know that’s rare but it's simply how I feel. They are awesome and I will never change.

Geico Home Insurance Reviews

Geico is very professional and friendly. It has the cheapest premium that I know off and the website/mobile app is every easy to use.

None that I can honestly think off. I have had no problems at all since signing up.

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I have always been pleased with this company. They know me as a person and as a customer. They understand my unique needs and desires for different coverages.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

The company is built on quality and superior service. I enjoy the comfort and peace of mind that it offers to me and my family.

The only thing I can say that I may dislike would be the amount I pay could be slightly lower. I do feel like the rates could be lower.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

The company has been honest and has good agents like our local agent. They stay in touch via email and the website is easy to navigate.

I have not yet submitted any type of claim. They are supposed to give a refund to those who do not have accidents

I don't have anything negative to say... I wish the premium was a little cheaper.

I don't really have a good understanding of my coverage. The details are seemingly falsified or deliberately vague

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

I like that the company works with all of their customers in a manner that's not always frustrating. They listen and try to offer their best solutions for the customers.

State Farm is a great company. They are very knowledgeable, get back promptly, and have great coverage.

I don't have to deal with them unless it's something I'm reaching out for. They're always had great customer service and have answered my questions quickly!

What I dislike is sometimes their rates. When there is a damage, it's pretty pricey and they don't always offer a discount.

Insurance is a necessary evil, and I agree that it's a good idea to have it. But I've been paying for ten years, and I could pay for another 50 more, and I'm paying for the possibility of damage, and if there never is any, I get no return on it. So it's not the company itself. Other than that, the site constantly reminding me about bundle stuff. Which I don't need.

No criticism at all about this company. I have recommended this company to others as they are right in town.

It's expensive! I'm not really sure how they compare to other companies so really I should do some checking on that. But regardless, insurance is expensive!

Amica Home Insurance Reviews

I like their customer service, and how easy their claim service has been in the past. it has been easy to work with them which makes me want to stay

Their pricing keeps going up each year, year after year. I would like it if the price stayed the same or decreased one of these years. It would be a nice change.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company