Top Colorado Home Insurance Providers Ranked By Homeowners

Colorado homeowners insurance is roughly $1,273. Our detailed guide reveals consumers can save as much as $445 by getting many quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Top Colorado Home Insurance Company Reviews & Ratings

Company Market Share (%) Average Rating No of Reviews
USAA 10.72
State Farm 20.63
Allstate 9.99
Progressive -
Safeco Insurance -
Liberty Mutual 9.13
Travelers 4.52
Farmer's Insurance -
MetLife -
American Family 9.83
Safeco -
Farmers Insurance 10.71
Nationwide 2.3
Amica -
National General -
Finance Insurance -
Centauri Insurance -
Amica Mutual Insurance -
Country Financial -
Plummer Insurance -
California Casualty -

Latest Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Safeco Home Insurance Reviews

They are national and well respected. The company is big enough to not go under so I am glad to have its stability. I like that they have a brick and mortar presence in my community.

I do apologize, but I don't have a specific grievance with the company. They are professional, courteous and don't give my wife or I any troubles.

National General Home Insurance Reviews

we are satisfied with the service provided by the company and website is very useful. we can access the website through mobile app also. the mobile app is very useful for the payment method for annual payment.

Travelers Home Insurance Reviews

I dislike their archaic website and some of their older policies

One thing I don't like so much about my insurance is that the car insurance premium went up about 200 dollars last year. But this year it went back down 150 so it's not all the worst.

As compare to other rental insurance, I think travelers is the best that I had experienced. Premium is not too high as some companies have.

GEICO Home Insurance Reviews

Geico is very professional and friendly. It has the cheapest premium that I know off and the website/mobile app is every easy to use.

The website is good and we can know all the details of our policy from the website after signing in.

I like everything about the company, their service, prices and overall they are great

I like the people that work and there and the fact that they are always there when I need them to be!

I don't like the limit to what they offer, and how some of the staff isn't knowledgable and I'm often transferred to someone else.

None that I can honestly think off. I have had no problems at all since signing up.

Finance Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I never dislike anything about this company I really trust on this company.I never dislike this company.

AMERIPRISE Home Insurance Reviews



Centauri Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

What I do not like about the company is its bad attention when it comes to directing to its offices and its bad orientation

Amica Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Overall, the company has answered any questions I ever have, even though I have not made a claim through them I have heard great things from family members about making claims. But other than that their customer service is great and they're always willing to do whatever they can.

Farmers Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I have always been pleased with this company. They know me as a person and as a customer. They understand my unique needs and desires for different coverages.

I do not dislike my insurance company at all. I do not care for the agent that took over for the original agent that I signed up with.

Safeco Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I would be open to trying a new insurance company out especially if it would save me money.

i do not like that they do not offer flood insurance. didi not find that out until my house was flooding from a storm

I liked how personable everybody is, from my agent to the customer service when I call. The are also the least expensive compared to other companies which is a plus

I like what is covered in my policy. Not only is my house, but the surrounding area around my house as well as jewelry. I like it's the cheapest option too for me.

The only think I dislike about the company is that my premium could be a little lower. My premium is cheaper than other companies, but still is a little on the expensive side.

I dislike that my premium is somewhat high, but it's still cheaper than other companies. I dislike that they nickel and dime you for every coverage.

Farmer's Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

I shop my insurance every 2-3 years and I have not found better or comparable coverage for less in the past 12 years.

A solid 4 out of 5. Not the best out there, but honestly works just fine for us. We just wanted something simple and affordable and this insurance company is doing what it set out to do - protect.

I think that they have a really good customer service team. The fact that I can call anytime in case of an emergency file or for a simple claim.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

The company is built on quality and superior service. I enjoy the comfort and peace of mind that it offers to me and my family.

It is a large well established company that has been around for over a century.3

Given the age of my house and value, I think the premium is extremely reasonable and competitive. When I lived in a new home in another geographical area my premium was over three times what I am paying now.

We get a bundle price because we have Auto and Homeowners insurance. The coverage is about average for today's standards.

The only thing I can say that I may dislike would be the amount I pay could be slightly lower. I do feel like the rates could be lower.

Country Financial Home Insurance Reviews

There is nothing that i dislike about the company. They have always provided me with everything i have needed throughout my adulthood

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

This company is an overall good company with both homeowners insurance and car insurance. They take their time and assist you with any problems and concerns and they make sure that you are covered any your claims are taken seriously

There is nothing that I really do not dislike. have not run into any problems with them with billing, customer service, nor my claims. This is a good company

USAA Home Insurance Reviews

Usaa is trustworthy and ethical. 2 things that aren't often found in business. I made sure when my children were born that they got usaa numbers of their own so they'd be able to use the services for life. I think that speaks volumes.

USaa takes care of military and their family they have a great attitude always help always kind

I am satisfied because they are attentive. I love the multi-policy discounts. I love the discount for being a service member. I love the fact that they only service the military community.

Good company to work with. Offer a lot of services online. Easy to apply and change coverage. Service reps readily available as required. Communication is dispensed as required.

I like how easy they make things for us. I also like how fast they make things happen. Their customer service is the best around,

USAA has a large number of incentive discounts available to long-time members of the financial institution. These discounts apply to insurance packages and offer a good deal of competitive pricing.

I like that I can bundle it in with everything else. At this point that is what I like about it the most. Easy to pay the bill every month since it is all in one.

GEICO responds quickly, handles a claim efficiently, and is always there when needed. I highly recommend GEICO to others.

My insurance for over 20 years and they haven't changed a bit in customer service and been satisfied always with them. The premium is low and they never failed me in any claims I had.

I like that USAA serves the military and offers a great product with a great price to boot. Overall, I'd say that I'm proud to be a member.

Easy to deal with, personnel are efficient, professional, always available, the local company, also offers to the bank, offices are easy to get to and plenty of parking.

I don't have anything negative to say about USAA, they are reliable, trustworthy, and have been my partner in life for quite a while now

So far the customer service has been great. When our dishwasher machine sprung a leak, they immediately sent out an adjuster and he provided a full agreement that we were covered. The floor was replaced and we got a new washer.

They get in touch with me I by mail or call. I have no complaints about communication

I think the premium could probably be cheaper. It was easier and more cost-effective to move my auto insurance to Farmers I would. But right now it doesn't seem worth the effort.

I couldn't be happier with our insurance company because I've been with them for years and know that they deliver on what they say they will do.

We have always used USAA so I can't compare to other companies, but we have hears some "horror stories" from neighbors on their claims process compared to USAA. USAA isn't a battle compared to other companies.

There is nothing I dislike about this company. It is a great company, and I don't think I would choose another company over it. I would recommend this company to my friends.

I really don't have any dislikes about the company. USSA has been in my family for years and will continue to be. My father and I have been members of USSA since 2010 and we will never look back.

We like that this company supports military families and has insurance for our house at an affordable price. This is great for us and we will never change insurance companies.

we are satisfied overall. NO other complaints. we have combined all our insurance needs without another thought.

They get the job done quickly and efficiently. I don't have to deal with any nonsense and double speak from the representative and my claims are taken care of completely. They don't leave anything undone and they have always asked me if there was anything else that I needed to put into the claim so nothing gets left out. They are thorough and it gives us peace of mind knowing that they will get the problem fixed right.

USAA really puts the customer first. They are easy to work with and make it a pleasure to conduct business. I will be a USAA member for life.

I love that my premium is low. I love that they answer your questions in a timely manner and that they are available 24/7.

Agent courtesy. Promptness of response and attentiveness in handling the claim. Damage amount: an estimate of the dollar amount of damages. Satisfaction with timely payment by the insurer.

There's not much i can say about not liking. I love them and will stay with them for life!

the only complaint I have is the change in cost from state to state

I really have never found anything I don't like about this company. I know that’s rare but it's simply how I feel. They are awesome and I will never change.

I don't really dislike anything about the company. They are pushing to become more automated but so is everyone else. For now, they still feel like they "know" me and that's what matters.

Nothing negative for me to say really other than that there are occasional times other companies can beat certain rates, but overall bundling it all together saves me a ton of money.

I have not found anything that I dislike about my insurance company. They have performed above all expectations

Sometimes I think that the premium is a little too high for the amount coverage they offer. Another thing is to reach a representative on the phone takes a little too long.

I dislike their website since it's sometimes hard to find what I want. It could use a good redesign. However, this is minor.

USAA has slowly been adding fees to all their services and dent that the fees are the new addition and their customer is trained to pretend that the fee we're always being applied. I have been a member of USAA since 2001 and I am well aware there were not added fees before.

I do not like it sometimes because they advertise to third parties

the decline in customer relations. If I came onto the company now I probably wouldn't notice but I have been a customer for 15 years so I have experienced the decline it is frustrating.

Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

The company has been honest and has good agents like our local agent. They stay in touch via email and the website is easy to navigate.

I have not yet submitted any type of claim. They are supposed to give a refund to those who do not have accidents

I don't really have a good understanding of my coverage. The details are seemingly falsified or deliberately vague

They send alerts or emails instead of endless promotions to my home. This is easier to keep track of and easier to file.

Comparing with others the company provide low premium they provide good response to the customer. They give respect to the customer. Premium paying and there is no stress about premium.

There isn't much to like about them. I only rated them a 3 on the satisfied scale because I've had the other insurance company available to me and they are far worse.

i like the rates, the coverage, the employees, the website, everything. i also have my auto insurance through them so they give me great savings and deal.s they acutally also reach out to help me lower my monthly payments/premium

My monthly payment is never the exact same amount, which is very confusing. It seems like it should be the same amount each month. That would make it easier for me to predict the monthly cost and set up my budget. Why would it differ from month to month?

Overall, I'm very satisfied with my home insurance company. They have been responsive and I'm sure I'd have a positive experience if I ever had to file a claim.

I like being able to sign in and see all my policies listed and am able to click on whichever one I want to access. It is also a convenient way to go online and pay my premiums.

I really have not had any contact with the company much since I signed the contract. They were very professional when getting my business.

I like the customer service provided by this company. We have been very happy with the speed of their responses when we have had questions about coverage. I have not yet submitted a claim, as we have only been with this company for about a year.

It is hard to cancel insurance with them. They are tricky about not entirely taking autos off of your policy when you ask them. (They have put a 5.00 a month hold on our auto policy for a truck I wanted to cancel and did not tell us). Also, they have recently pressured me for payment of my auto premium when I switched one of the household cars to Progressive to save money during a time of financial trouble.

from all my experience with the company I like everything about it. This could change in the future but since I haven't had any real dealings with them, I am completely satisfied for the time being.


I don't have anything negative to say... I wish the premium was a little cheaper.

I cannot say anything about what I like or dislike about the company's website because I have not visited the company's website.

I like everything. THere has not been a time where I do not like something at this time.

I don't have any dislikes, at all. I don't have any dislikes here or there or anywhere. I am very happy with this company.

Our premiums are very high because of flood insurance, which is of course, unpleasant. Obviously, I'd rather not have to pay flood coverage.

Plummer Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Our insurance company doesn't have any customer discount incentive. I wish they offer some kind of bonus if you go a specific amount of time without an accident or claim.

Amica Home Insurance Reviews

I like their customer service, and how easy their claim service has been in the past. it has been easy to work with them which makes me want to stay

Their pricing keeps going up each year, year after year. I would like it if the price stayed the same or decreased one of these years. It would be a nice change.

MetLife Home Insurance Reviews

The insurance rep that came to look over our property had an "I'm better than you" attitude. He wasn't very pleasant to deal with and when I called to complain about him I was informed that he has had complaints before.

I don't like their calls. From database they will take our number and call weekly twice or thrice and ask me to suggest few friends.

Indifferent - never had to use them for anything. At this point I only pay them because my loan requires it.

American Family Home Insurance Reviews

We have been with the company a long time and have always received prompt service. One agent even called us to see how our move to another town went.

I like the value I get for the money I pay. I do not care for how frequently the insurance agent bothers me about adding additional insurance policies.

The only thing I have been unhappy with was that when our agent retired, his replacement did not last long, but the company quickly assigned us another agent.

California Casualty Home Insurance Reviews

Overall I looked at nine different companies before I switched providers and far and away this was the best service for the best price. I really have enjoyed working with them so far.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

I just like everything about the company overall. I get a cheap price, great support, and fantastic protection. I know if anything ever happens I will be covered and treated respectfully.

I like that they had an endorsement for my dog, which is an Akita and normally cause for insurance to be canceled.

I feel that it is a little pricey but I am comfortable paying it.

I dislike their website navigation, its hard just to log in. Also, dislike that they don't seem to get back to you when they say they will (from phone calls)

They have a nice line of BS for me to listen to every year. I suppose they should be nice. Since it is the least they can do after cheating the hell out of me!

They truly don't care. They know that there are limited options in the area and are not very customer service oriented at all.

I can't think of anything I dislike about them. I mean sure it could be even cheaper, but they are already the cheapest I found around me, so why would they lose money for no reason?

Do not have anything to dislike about them. We have not had any issues with them. I have not had any reports or claims filed so have not had to interact too much with them.

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

Communication with the company is non-existent.

I like that the company works with all of their customers in a manner that's not always frustrating. They listen and try to offer their best solutions for the customers.

I like that every encounter with this company has been pleasant and I felt like I was taken care of properly. I have not true complaints. The website, customer service, and claims submission have all been an adventure in easy navigation.

Overall the company has a good reputation. They have a good website and mobile app. Their agents are very knowledgeable.

They're friendly, easygoing people who are always available to help. I've never had an issue with a bill or an employee or anything at all that I can think of.

State Farm is a great company. They are very knowledgeable, get back promptly, and have great coverage.

I don't have to deal with them unless it's something I'm reaching out for. They're always had great customer service and have answered my questions quickly!

Overall, I like that the company is there for people to have jobs in a world that demands them after school. I hope they get to keep working there during any kind of work transition in the world as long as they're stable.

This is safer and better option than the other insurance companies. I am completely satisfied with the company

My premium may be a little more than other homeowners insurance companies, I feel like I get better service with State Farm. My agent tailors my account to me and provides excellent service.

They are very fast to react. They clear any doubt that I have at any point of time. I like them.

the facility that gives of payment that is to say it has a plan of payments of premium that are accessible to the people his attention to the client is very good and the coverage of his insurance is wide

Friendly Customer service focused from the beginning and even now years into the relationship Company and agent have great reputation and expertise 9

I like my home insurance company because they are friendly and answer all my questions and help me in my first homeowner process

I always have a great interaction with their customer service for over the past 8 months and they always help me with anything I need help with

I don't like that it takes a while to get in touch with someone when I have a question or have a problem with my insurance.

I like the ease of and usability, their rate calculators and chat access availability.

I have been with State Farm for a very long time and will not switch to another company. I like their service.

I can't think of anything I dislike about State Farm. I suppose it would be great if the premiums are lower, but I feel that the premiums are very reasonable.

There is nothing I dislike about the company. I do not think they are a good company at all and I hope they are around for a long time.

The company makes an effort to be price competitive. The bundling pricing is attractive. Having a dedicated agent is good. I have dealt with the same office staff of two assistants for about 24 years.

I am very satisfied with my insurance company. I think they are great and have gone above and beyond to meet my family's entire needs. They have my service for life. They have always looked out for my best interest and make sure I have complete information.

The customer service I received from Jen at State Farm is second to none. She is absolutely amazing in her customer relations and is extremely helpful.

What I dislike is sometimes their rates. When there is a damage, it's pretty pricey and they don't always offer a discount.

Insurance is a necessary evil, and I agree that it's a good idea to have it. But I've been paying for ten years, and I could pay for another 50 more, and I'm paying for the possibility of damage, and if there never is any, I get no return on it. So it's not the company itself. Other than that, the site constantly reminding me about bundle stuff. Which I don't need.

It's expensive! I'm not really sure how they compare to other companies so really I should do some checking on that. But regardless, insurance is expensive!

Due to the large number of customers they have, they take time to respond to the customer

No criticism at all about this company. I have recommended this company to others as they are right in town.

Please take a moment to write review on your home insurance company