Brookhaven Insurance Rates:

Brookhaven, NY homeowners insurance is roughly $541 to $732, about $45-$61/month. Our thorough guide reveals consumers can save as much as $254 by getting different quotes. Enter your zipcode below and click “GO” to get multiple free quotes.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Latest Home Insurance Reviews

Progressive
The progressive insurance company has not had much contact with us regarding our home insurance when we purchased it, only our auto insurance.
Usaa
Usaa is an insurance and banking company that is only for veterans and their families. because it is a company that was created just for veterans, they really try to ensure that our heroes that have fought for our country are taken care of.
Usaa
Usaa is generally quick to respond to you when you have questions or want to discuss the features of your policy.
State Farm
I don't like how lately my billing has been very messed up. They were charging me monthly for an already paid in full policy.
State Farm
They've always been very easy to contact and I've been able to communicate my needs easily with them.
Farmer's Insurance
They are very friendly and is always willing to help us when we go in to see her. She is always looking for ways to save us money and also give us tips on things the company is looking for us to do with our home to optimize our coverage.
State Farm
I'm extremely satisfied with my premium. It is very affordable and doesn't break the bank so to speak since I'm on a budget.
Homesite Insurance
Not very happy with their website; minimal information is available. I think they are trying to cut costs so they have a crappy website.
Travelers
There really is nothing I can say that I dislike about the company, it all was set up and seems easy to use and I am covered.
State Farm
There really isn't much that I like about this company. I like that they are well known. I like that they have home and auto insurance.
Erie Insurance
Very straightforward and easy to understand. After a few minutes of navigating, I was able to understand where everything was I was looking for.
Union Mutual
THEY OFFER A GREAT PACKAGE INCLUDING APPLIANCE BREAKDOWN AND REPAIR FOR A VERY RESONABLE PRICE. THEIR POLICY PAPERWORK IS EASY TO UNDERSTAND. WE HAVENT HAD TO USE THEM YET IN OUR NEW HOME, BUT WE ARE VERY COMFORTABLE WITH WHAT THE POLICY COVERS.
Allstate
The agency I use is very nice. They are always friendly and helpful. I really can't think of a dislike for them
Usaa
I like USAA because it supports veterans, it has a lot of options, it seems more personable and it gives discounts for the more products you use them. I have used them for years for banking, mortgages, insurance, and credit and I have never had a bad time with them.
State Farm
They don't seem very smart and it makes us question why we went with this company over a smaller company because we are just another customer to them.
Allstate
I am very happy with them. They are always very helpful and caring and know what they are doing.
Usaa
They cater to military families. They understand the struggle of the spouse not always being around, or that you may need to move over and over again.
State Farm
Compare the top homeowner's insurance companies in the areas of customer service, pricing, financial strength and claims service.If you are not adequately insured, you could experience catastrophic losses.An insurance company who rates highly in the area of customer satisfaction is one
Usaa
USAA offers great prices for insurance. Being apart of the military provides a great deal that most companies cant match. If anyone is eligible, I highly recommend they join.
Usaa
USAA has great customer service and their website is easy to use. Their prices are fairly reasonable and they are readily available to take your claim.
Progressive
Overall I like the structure of the company website and their multi-policy discount. It is easy to find information about the coverage and proof of insurance on the website.
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
I like that I get to work with one person from start to finish. I like that almost everything is covered for a reasonable price and I like the communication they have with me.
Usaa
We have had USAA insurance for many years. They are always there when we need them for our home care needs as well as renters insurance. Customer service is outstanding and they treat you like a person instead of a number.

Brookhaven, NY Homeowners Insurance By Home Value

Brookhaven, NY Home Value Total Homes % of Total Average Brookhaven, NY Homeowners Insurance
Less than $50,000 1,663 1.0% $44
$100,000 to $124,999 1,764 2.0% $197
$125,000 to $149,999 1,562 1.0% $248
$150,000 to $174,999 2,648 3.0% $292
$175,000 to $199,999 3,125 3.0% $337
$200,000 to $249,999 11,425 13.0% $407
$250,000 to $299,999 17,703 20.0% $496
$300,000 to $399,999 44,746 51.0% $629

Top Home Insurance Agents Near Brookhaven, NY

Home Insurance Company Near Brookhaven, NY Homeowners Insurance Agency Near Brookhaven, NY Address
Travelers Fitzharris & Company 333 EARLE OVINGTON BLVD STE 215, UNIONDALE, NY, 11553
Travelers Marlin Insurance Agency Inc 1138 William Floyd Pkwy Unit 3, Shirley, NY, 11967
Travelers Massapequa L H Inc 3245 MERRICK RD, WANTAGH, NY, 11793
Travelers Stanley Schusterman Inc 175 GREAT NECK ROAD STE 404, GREAT NECK, NY, 11022
Allstate Winston Brodmerkel 352 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY, 11801

Cost Of Homeowners Insurance By Street Near Brookhaven, NY

Streets in Brookhaven Area Homeowners Insurance Cost
Field House Ave, Richard Pl, Private Ln, Hiawatha Ln, Wauwepex Trl, Mercedes Ct, West Walk, Terry St, la Bonne Vie Dr, Lakewood Rd$644
Walter Ave, Potter St, Gen McLean Dr, Inwood Ave, Brewster Dr, Wyngate Ln, Sunwood Dr, Hempstead Ave, Wildwood St, Daniel Way$661
Hadley Ct, Forsythe Meadow Rd, Seacliff Ln, Corpine Ln, Reynolds Rd, W Woodside Ave, Amagansett Ct, Alex Ct, Jayne Blvd, Underhill Ct$678
Birchfield Ct, Eastview Dr, Stafford Ln, E Bartlett Rd, Hulse St, Courtney Dr, Roosevelt Ct, Mayflower Ln, Jarvis Ln, Edgar Ave$632
Arbor Field Way, Fawn Ln W, Chapel Hill Rd, Blossom Ave, Wisteria Dr, Woodstock Pl, Victory Knoll Path, Islip Dr, Ashland St, Wagon Ln S$652
Lowery Ave, Montpelier Ct, Havens Ave, Barbara Rd, Southview Cir, Thorburn Ave, Fawn Ct, Shenandoah Blvd, Charman Ave, Co Ed$641
Vivian Ln, Sea View Walk, Golf Ln, Hale St, Rocky Point Yaphank Rd, Norfleet Ln, Bari Ln, Aster Pl, Clematis Path, Laurel Rd W$622
Hines Rd, Chapel Ave, Pawntucket Ct, Robin Rd, Woodruff St, Donack Ave, Dawn Rd, Honey Ln W, Davidia Ln, Pace Ave$602
Burney Blvd, Hollow Ct, Wellington Ct, S Evergreen Dr, Furman Ln, Huck Finn Ln, Kingston Rd, Handcock Pl, Balin Ct N, Buccaneer Ln$654
Midwood Pl, Linda St, Oakcrest Ave, Mather Dr, Gardenia Rd, Seatuck Cove Cir, Primrose Path, Yava St, Bay View Walk, Avery Ave$634

Brookhaven, NY Home Insurance Savings For Senior Occupied Homes

PlaceSavings For Senior Occupied Homes
Brookhaven$95 to $97
Gordon Heights$93
Yaphank$94
Farmingville$95

Brookhaven, NY Auto & Homeowners Insurance Bundling Discounts

Place 1 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance 2 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance 3 Car Bundle Savings On Insurance
Gordon Heights CDP, New York $78 $103 $155
Middle Island CDP, New York $78 $104 $156
Yaphank CDP, New York $79 $105 $158

Brookhaven, NY Area Home Insurance as a % of Housing Cost

PlaceHome insurance as a % of housing cost for homes with mortgageHome insurance as a % of housing cost for homes without mortgage
Brookhaven, NY2.0%5.3%
Gordon Heights2.12%5.19%
Middle Island2.3%5.53%
Yaphank2.03%6.1%

Brookhaven Renters Insurance as a Percentage of Rent

Brookhaven Home By Monthly Rent Total Homes % of Total Estimated Monthly Income To Afford Rented House Including Renters Insurance
$200 to $299 488 1.0% $776
$300 to $499 875 2.0% $1226
$500 to $749 1,196 3.0% $1901
$750 to $999 1,835 5.0% $2651
$1,000 to $1,499 10,479 33.0% $3776
$1,500 or more 16,233 52.0% $5426