Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Evansville, Indiana, with its Midwest charm and robust cultural scene, is a city where many seek to put down roots. When it comes to insuring homes in this region, several factors come into play due to the city's unique location and economic conditions.


Top Competitors and Their Prices

The leading insurance providers in Evansville, and an approximate range of their home insurance rates, are as follows:

  • State Farm: Known for a strong local presence, rates might range from $600 to $2,000 annually.

  • Allstate: With customizable policy options, Allstate's rates could be between $650 and $2,100 per year.
  • Indiana Farm Bureau: As a local provider, their rates may vary from $550 to $1,800 annually.
  • Erie Insurance: They offer competitive pricing that could range from $500 to $1,700 per year.
  • Liberty Mutual: With a broad coverage offer, rates could span from $650 to $2,200 annually.
  • American Family Insurance: They may provide quotes ranging from $600 to $2,000 yearly.


Analysis On Quotes, Rates & Agents

  • Quotes: To generate a quote in Evansville, insurers will assess the home’s replacement cost, its age, the homeowner's insurance score (credit-based), and any safety features installed in the home.

  • Rates: The rates in Evansville are competitive due to the city's relatively low risk for natural disasters and a stable housing market. However, the potential for tornadoes and severe storms can influence the rates slightly higher.
  • Agents: Local agents are instrumental in providing tailored information. They understand the specific risks in Evansville, such as weather-related damage potential, and can assist homeowners in finding discounts for which they may be eligible, like those for bundling policies or installing safety devices.


Factors Influencing Insurance Rates in Evansville, IN

  • Weather Risks: Evansville is susceptible to tornadoes and severe weather, which can raise the potential for claims and, subsequently, insurance rates.
  • Crime Rates: Higher crime rates in certain neighborhoods can lead to increased rates due to the higher risk of theft and vandalism.
  • Property Values: The value of the home and the cost to rebuild are significant factors in determining insurance premiums.
  • Claims History: If the area has a history of numerous claims, insurers may increase premiums to account for this risk.
  • Personal Credit Score: In Indiana, credit scores can be used to determine insurance rates, with higher scores often leading to lower premiums.
  • Proximity to Fire Services: Homes closer to fire stations and hydrants often receive lower rates due to the decreased risk of total loss from a fire.
  • Age and Condition of the Home: Older homes, or those in poor condition, can expect higher rates due to the increased likelihood of a claim.


In Evansville, homeowners can choose from a variety of reputable insurance providers offering competitive rates. The cost of insurance will be influenced by both personal factors, such as credit history and claims records, and external factors, such as the local weather patterns and crime rates. It's crucial for homeowners to work closely with local agents who can guide them through the nuances of purchasing home insurance in Evansville, ensuring they have adequate coverage while also taking advantage of any available discounts. Regularly reviewing and comparing insurance policies can help homeowners stay ahead of any changes that might affect their rates, keeping their home insurance costs as favorable as possible.