Homeowners in Fort Wayne, Indiana, pay an average home insurance rate ranging between $684 and $925. vHome’s comprehensive analysis reveals that Fort Wayne homeowners can save up to $321 by comparing quotes from multiple home insurance providers. Below are the top 5 home insurance companies in Indiana according to market share.

State Farm

State Farm is the leading home insurance provider in Indiana with a market share of 25.26%. It has written direct premiums worth $502,702 and has earned direct premiums worth $496,726. State Farm holds a financial strength rating of A++ from A.M. Best for its superior financial capacity in granting potential claims of current Fort Wayne policyholders. It also received a customer satisfaction score of 4/5 from J.D. Power based on the feedback collected from policyholders.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual comes second to State Farm in terms of market share with 8.07%. The home insurance company has direct premiums written worth $160,548, and direct premiums earned worth $155,363. A.M. Best rated Liberty Mutual with an A for its excellent ability to grant potential claims of current policyholders. In terms of overall customer satisfaction, Liberty Mutual received a score of 3/5 from J.D Power.

Allstate

Allstate is another major player in the home insurance segment, with a market share of 8.05%. The home insurance company has direct premiums written worth $160,309, and direct premiums earned worth $153,528. Allstate has the superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current Fort Wayne policyholders and has been awarded a rating of A+ from A.M. Best. It received a customer satisfaction score of 3/5 from J.D. Power.

American Family

American Family occupies a market share of 6.43% with direct premiums written worth $128,036, and direct premiums earned worth $123,914. It has received a financial strength rating of A for its excellent ability to grant claims of current policyholders. J.D. Power has awarded a score of 3/5 on customer satisfaction.

Erie

According to NAIC data, Erie occupies a market share of 5.59% in Indiana. The total value of direct premiums written and earned are $111,355 and $109,433, respectively. Erie has received a financial strength rating of A+ for its superior financial strength to grant potential claims of current Fort Wayne policyholders. It is also one of the very few home insurance companies to have received a perfect customer satisfaction score of 5/5 from J.D. Power.