Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Green Bay, WI, with its rich football legacy and strong community ties, has a stable real estate market and experiences distinct seasons, factors that both play into the cost of home insurance.


Top Home Insurance Competitors in Green Bay, WI

  • American Family Insurance: With roots in the Midwest, American Family offers competitive rates often ranging from $400 to $1,000 annually, reflecting a deep understanding of Wisconsin's specific insurance needs.

  • State Farm: A major player in the home insurance game, State Farm offers Green Bay residents rates that could vary widely from $350 to $1,200 per year, with discounts for bundling and home safety features.
  • Allstate: Known for its customizable policy options, Allstate’s rates in the Green Bay area tend to be between $400 and $1,300 annually, depending on the coverage levels and discounts applied.
  • Erie Insurance: Erie provides region-specific coverage with a reputation for customer satisfaction and rates that can range from $300 to $1,000 a year in Green Bay, contingent on several factors, including the age of the home.
  • Progressive: With competitive pricing and various discounts, Progressive’s rates for Green Bay homeowners could span from $350 to $1,100 per year, catering to a broad demographic.


Analysis of Quotes, Rates & Agents

  • Quotes: Obtaining an accurate quote in Green Bay involves considering the size, age, and construction type of the home. Online tools from these insurers can provide quick estimates, but direct interaction with agents can result in more personalized quotes.

  • Rates: The rates in Green Bay reflect the broader Wisconsin market, which is generally more affordable than the national average. Rates are competitive, but insurers will consider the individual risk factors associated with each homeowner.
  • Agents: Local agents are key to navigating the home insurance landscape in Green Bay. They have firsthand knowledge of local weather patterns, housing trends, and can advise on appropriate coverage levels.


Factors Influencing Insurance Rates in Green Bay, WI

  • Weather Conditions: Green Bay’s weather, including cold winters with heavy snowfall, can affect insurance rates due to the risk of frozen pipes, snow damage, and other cold-related issues.

  • Proximity to Water Bodies: Being near the bay, properties closer to water could have higher rates due to the increased risk of flooding.
  • Local Fire Protection: Homes near well-equipped fire stations and with fire hydrants close by may benefit from lower rates.
  • Neighborhood Crime Rates: Areas with higher crime rates may see increased premiums due to the elevated risk of theft and vandalism.
  • Home’s Construction and Condition: Older homes or those with outdated utilities might attract higher rates. Conversely, newer homes or those with recent updates may be eligible for lower rates.
  • Personal Claims History: A history of claims can lead to higher premiums for homeowners due to perceived increased risk.
  • Credit Score: In Wisconsin, as in many states, credit scores can be a determining factor for insurance rates.
  • Discount Opportunities: Many insurers offer discounts for bundled services, security systems, non-smoking households, and more, which can significantly impact the final rate.


Green Bay’s home insurance market offers a range of options to fit the unique needs of its homeowners. Premiums are influenced by local conditions such as weather risks, property location, and individual homeowner characteristics. It is essential for Green Bay residents to work with knowledgeable local agents who can guide them through the process of selecting the right coverage, taking advantage of discounts, and ultimately securing a rate that reflects their specific circumstances. Regular reviews of policies are also advisable to adjust to any changes in the home’s condition, the local environment, or the homeowner’s personal circumstances.