Homeowners in York, PA, generally choose a home insurance company that offers the cheapest insurance rates. However, several other factors are taken into consideration to determine the best home insurance companies in York.
State Farm has registered itself as one of the most prominent home insurance companies in York, with its superior (A++) financial ability to fulfill potential claims of current York policyholders, and a customer satisfaction score of 3/5 from J.D. Power. State Farm is the largest home insurance provider in Pennsylvania, with a market share of 17.73%.
Erie is one of the two companies in York to receive a perfect customer satisfaction score of 5/5 based on feedback from home insurance policyholders. It has a financial strength rating of A+ (superior) from A.M. Best, making it a very reliable home insurance company in York. Erie holds a 15.54% market share in Pennsylvania.
Allstate is noted for its superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current York policyholders and has a rating of A+ from A.M. Best. Based on customer feedback curated by J.D. Power, Allstate has been awarded a customer satisfaction score of 3/5. According to the data collected by NAIC, Allstate has a 13.33% market share in Pennsylvania.
Liberty is another major home insurance provider in York, with a state market share of 8.33%. Liberty received a rating of A from A.M. Best for its excellent ability in granting potential claims of current York policyholders. J.D. Power awarded Liberty a customer satisfaction score of 2/5 based on a consumer survey.
Nationwide holds an A.M. Best rating of A+ for its superior financial ability in fulfilling potential claims of current York policyholders. In terms of customer satisfaction, it has a score of 2/5 based on customer feedback collected by J.D. Power. Nationwide occupies a market share of 7.70% in Pennsylvania.