Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Homeowners in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, pay an average home insurance rate of $780. Milwaukee homeowners can compare insurance quotes from multiple home insurance companies to choose the cheapest one. Below are the top 5 home insurance companies in Milwaukee, WI, by market share.

American Family

American Family is the leading provider of home insurance services in Milwaukee, occupying a market share of 21.22% in Wisconsin. The home insurance company has written direct premiums worth $315,155 and earned direct premiums worth $309,585. A.M. Best has awarded it with a financial strength rating of A for its excellent financial ability in granting potential claims of current Milwaukee policyholders. It holds a customer satisfaction score of 3/5 based on the feedback collected from policyholders by J.D. Power.

the_best_milwaukee_wi_home_insurance_companies

State Farm

State Farm occupies the second position in Wisconsin in terms of market share with 16.44%. The total value of direct premiums written and earned by State Farm is $244,183 and $238,485, respectively. A.M. Best has awarded it with a financial strength rating of A++ for its superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current Milwaukee policyholders. It holds a customer satisfaction score of 4/5 based on the feedback collected from policyholders by J.D. Power.

Erie

Erie follows State Farm in terms of market share, with 4.46%. The total value of direct premiums written and earned by Erie is $66,225 and $62,209, respectively. It has received a financial strength rating of A+ from A.M. Best for its superior financial ability to grant claims of current policyholders. Based on the feedback curated by J.D. Power, Erie has a perfect customer satisfaction score of 5/5.

Allstate

Allstate has a market share of 4.22%, with direct premiums written worth $62,665, and direct premiums earned worth $61,218. Allstate has the superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current Milwaukee policyholders and has been awarded a rating of A+ from A.M. Best. It received a customer satisfaction score of 3/5 from J.D. Power.

Liberty Mutual

According to NAIC data, Liberty Mutual holds a market share of 3.91% in Wisconsin. The home insurance company has direct premiums written worth $58,122, and direct premiums earned worth $56,695. A.M. Best rated Liberty Mutual with an A for its excellent ability to grant potential claims of current policyholders. In terms of overall customer satisfaction, Liberty Mutual received a score of 3/5 from J.D power.