Home insurance rates in Hayward, California, range from $535 to $724. Hayward homeowners can reduce their home insurance rates by choosing the cheapest home insurance company based on their needs. vHome’s analysis reveals that Hayward homeowners can save as much as $251 by comparing and choosing the cheapest quote. Below are the top home insurance companies in Hayward, CA, by market share.

State Farm

State Farm is the most prominent company in California, occupying the major market share of 17.56%. It has written direct premiums worth $1,469,169 and earned direct premiums worth $1,405,885. A.M. Best has awarded it with a financial strength rating of A++ for its superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current Hayward policyholders. It holds a customer satisfaction score of 4/5 based on the feedback collected from policyholders by J.D. Power.

Farmers

According to NAIC, Farmers occupies a market share of 15.97%. The total value of direct premiums written and earned by Farmers is $1,335,894 and $1,293,054, respectively. It has received a financial strength rating of A+ from A.M. Best for its superior financial ability to grant claims of current policyholders. Based on the feedback curated by J.D. Power, Farmers has a customer satisfaction score of 3/5.

CSAA

CSAA follows Farmers in terms of market share, occupying 6.51% of the share. It has direct premiums written and earned with a total value of $544,788 and $527,552, respectively. CSAA has an excellent financial ability for granting potential claims, with an A rating by A.M. Best. J.D. Power has awarded CSAA with a rating of 3/5 on customer satisfaction.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual has a market share of 6.24% in California with direct premiums written worth $521,782, and direct premiums earned worth $501,655. A.M. Best rated Liberty Mutual with an A for its excellent ability to grant potential claims of current policyholders. In terms of overall customer satisfaction, Liberty Mutual received a score of 3/5 from J.D Power.

Allstate

Allstate is another major player in the home insurance segment, with a market share of 5.91%. The home insurance company has direct premiums written worth $494,685, and direct premiums earned worth 488,052. Allstate has the superior financial ability in granting potential claims of current Hayward policyholders and has been awarded a rating of A+ from A.M. Best. It received a customer satisfaction score of 3/5 from J.D. Power.